4.1. Mercury content in bones
The detection of measurable mercury concentrations in cremated bone is somewhat surprising, even in those samples that were exposed at high temperatures, i.e., calcined. Elemental mercury volatilizes at relatively low temperatures (Hg° is released at 150°), while other mercury species are retained until higher temperatures (HgS gets mainly released at 400°) (Carvalhinho Windmöller et al. 2017). In our samples, we have observed a general trend towards a decrease of mercury concentration and variability with increasing temperature. Therefore, there is a temperature-effect in mercury concentration. This agrees with the observed Hg association to the presence of OH− (3578, 621 cm− 1), collagen bands such as amide II (1561, 1525 cm− 1) and III (1246 cm− 1), ν1PO43− (1028 cm− 1) and with its decrease in more crystalline samples (high 961, 591, 552 cm− 1.absorbances) and samples with cyanamide (2010, 700 cm− 1), i.e., high temperature. However, despite displaying the human samples the higher burning degree, their mercury concentrations tend to be higher (five samples being over the average) than unburnt dog samples, which display values below average – suggesting a species effect also in mercury concentration. The coexistence of both effects -temperature and animal species- as well as different Hg species, points towards the presence of strong mercury bonds in human remains that allowed for the retention of mercury in bone despite being burnt at low-mid temperatures, and discard any kind of diagenetic incorporation.
Archaeological bone can incorporate mercury during diagenesis when buried in soils rich in mercury (such as those close to mercury mines or formed from parent materials rich in this heavy metal), but this is not the case of Swedish soils. If mercury came from a modern contamination of topsoils (Panagos et al. 2021), no differences between species would exist. Thus, diagenetic incorporation is not likely in this case. In a previous investigation from our team (Álvarez-Fernández et al. 2022), we observed an inverse relationship between mercury and bioapatite crystallinity in inhumated skeletons. However, in the present study, we did not observe any correlation between IRSF and mercury concentration although we did observe a temperature effect - the higher the temperature, the lower mercury concentration in bone is. These two observations led us to discard a post-mortem diagenetic incorporation of mercury in our samples. Also, in the aforementioned investigation (Álvarez-Fernández et al. 2022) our team found that mercury was sourced from two different processes: i) ante-mortem incorporation during life, and ii) post-mortem bonding during soft tissues decay, especially from kidneys and liver (target organs for mercury intoxication) (García et al. 2001) leading to an intra-skeletal effect. Usually, in cremation funerary practices, the deceased individuals are burnt before the decomposition of soft tissues takes place. However, the incomplete combustion of the organic fraction under low burning temperatures observed in some of the samples (French et al. 2022), could have led to the retention of mercury in the carbon deposited during the cremation.
Carbon atoms in cremated bones can also come from exogenous sources such as the wood from the pyre (Zazzo et al. 2012). However, the observed differences in mercury concentration between species cannot be explained by mercury from the deposited carbon from the wood of the pyre. The presence of mercury could also be related to the degree of oxygen availability during burning, which would explain its positive correlation with OH− and negative correlation with cyanamide. Mercury concentration could be higher in samples burnt under oxidizing conditions and lower in samples burnt under reducing conditions, a fact that can be linked to the highest concentrations in crania, fibula and humerus, areas burnt more quickly than thoracic bones. More systematic studies sampling various body locations with the same degree of burning would be necessary to test this hypothesis.
Based on the results presented here and comparison with previous studies, we interpret that the mercury incorporation happened during life instead of coming from post-mortem alteration. However, when compared to other studied sites referred in the literature (see table in Álvarez-Fernández et al. 2020), the observed Hg concentrations are lower (17.1 ± 19.46 ng.g− 1) than the mercury levels documented for inhumated human remains from rural Medieval Denmark (Rasmussen et al. 2008; Rasmussen et al. 2017; Rasmussen et al. 2015) or the post-Roman A Lanzada in Spain (Álvarez-Fernández et al. 2020; López-Costas et al. 2020). The lack of coetaneous studies on inhumated remains in Sweden makes it impossible to determine whether the low levels are due to the effect of fire or to a low exposure to mercury pollution. In all cases, the low detection limit of the triple-cell DMA equipment used here opens the door to exploring ante-mortem mercury pollution through the study of cremated bones and its potential to be used as a proxy of the temperature achieved during burning.
4.2. Colour as temperature indicator
Most bones in this study fall into m-Stiner grade 6 (A and B), which could indicate either a good burning of the samples or it may respond to the fact that calcined bone is less susceptible to diagenesis, since the HAp crystals are bigger and more stable (Gallo et al. 2021). It is important to bear in mind that changes between m-Stiner grades of burning for this collection may be reflecting not only structural differences originated by the burning process at different temperatures and time of exposure, but also by differential diagenetic alteration since samples from grade 3 were more prone to diagenesis than samples from grade 6. Walker et al. (2008) pointed out that factors such as presence of organic compounds and oxygen availability have a greater influence in colour changes than time of exposure to fire.
We detected that macroscopic observation, in spite of being informative, non-destructive and affordable (Evans et al. 2022), does not completely match the information obtained by IR spectroscopy. Part of this disagreement may be explained by the inter-observer effect, and subjectivity of the macroscopic analysis (Krap et al. 2017). The differences we observed in the macroscopic m-Stiner assignation, and the spectroscopic data may be related to the fact that changes in colour are not only determined by the heating temperature but also by the time bone is exposed to heat (Greiner et al. 2019). Complete loss of organics can occur at ~ 300°C and calcination can start at ~ 550°C with long-exposure heating times (Gallo et al. 2023). However, this does not seem to be the case for our samples, since the relationship of colour and IR parameters, when looking at m-Stiner classification, and the MIR-indices and PCs although not being perfect it is relatively strong, and it is even improved when comparing IR values with analytical colour values.
Analytical colour analyses in the CIELab space have proven to be reliable temperature indicators before (Krap et al. 2019; Rubio et al. 2020). In our study, we analysed bones from different species and probably subjected to higher temperatures (m-Stiner grade 6B; >900ºC). Like Rubio et al. (2020), we observed that L* decreases with temperature until 400°C and then it increases again. We observed a new slight decrease at m-Stiner grade 6B that Rubio et al. (2020) did not observe, but these authors only studied samples heated at a maximum temperature of 800°C. Also, those authors observed that a* and b*were higher for samples heated at temperatures lower than 400°C and then they decreased drastically, which agrees with our results. Paba et al. (2021) also observed a slight decrease of L* from 900ºC to 1000ºC. Krap et al. (2019; 2024) proved that L* and b* values have high potential for estimating burning temperature even in faunal remains and embalmed human remains.
Walker et al. (2008) found that, to some extent, analytical colour measured in the RGB system was a good predictor of collagen content. This agrees with our results since we have found that collagen bands correlate with colour parameters: for samples with observable 1600, 1560, 1524 cm− 1 intensities the peak absorbance correlates negatively with L*, and positively with a* and b*, indicating that samples with collagen would be redder, yellower, and darker. This opens the door for using analytical colour as a predictor for collagen presence in bones. However, Gallo et al. (2023) observed that samples heated at 300°C during prolonged time exposure (48 hours), did not achieve calcination even though the samples presented pale colour, thereby, caution must be taken when inferring temperature by bone coloration. Other factors, such as the presence of iron and manganese oxides, may also produce dark colours even at high-temperature exposure (Michel et al. 2006). However, it does not seem the case for our samples, since the spectroscopic signal and the analytical colour values display good correlation.
4.3. Interpreting the PCA results
For the studied samples, PC1N represents collagen vs. phosphate content; PC2N represents carbonate abundance relative to phosphate; PC3N represents the relative intensity of 961 and 872 cm− 1 (temperature-related bands) versus 560 cm− 1; PC4N represents the relative intensity of 1088 versus 560 cm− 1 and PC5N represents the relative intensity of the 598 cm− 1 band. The scores are projected in Supplementary Fig. 5. Even though we have classified these samples as a group, scores for PC1N show that bone samples with m-Stiner grade 0 have higher values compared to those classified as m-Stiner grades 2, 3, 4 and 5, which indicates that burning affects collagen content even at low temperatures. Also, human samples show relatively higher positive scores for PC2N, indicating that this group may present higher carbonate-to-phosphate content than horse and dog samples. Most of the samples have negative scores for PC3N except for Tyr094, Tyr091, Tyr101, Tyr105, Tyr013, Tyr082, Tyr092, Tyr096, Tyr050 and Tyr107. PC4N shows large positive scores for Tyr101 and Tyr102 and large negative scores for Tyr091 and Tyr013. PC5N shows especially high positive scores for Tyr085 and Tyr050 and high negative scores for Tyr101 and Tyr104.
Regarding PCAC, the results indicate that, PC1C represents ν4, ν3PO43− and amide versus ν2CO32− and ν1PO43−. PC2C represents carbonate content versus 698 cm− 1 and OH−. PC3C shows ν4PO43− and OH− to 698 cm− 1. PC4C shows the ratio of OH− versus cyanamide and 698 cm− 1. PC5C represents A-type carbonate-to-OH−, and PC6C shows 1086 cm− 1 versus 961 cm− 1. The scores for PCAC are projected in supplementary Fig. 6. For PC1C most samples classified as 6B show negative scores while samples classified as 6A and 5 show mainly positive scores for this component. The bands involved in this component are temperature-related, which indicates that samples classified as m-Stiner grade 6B experienced a reverse chemical transformation of the phosphates and carbonate components of the hydroxyapatite compared with those classified as 6A and 5, that presumingly achieved lower temperatures than the former. For PC2C 6A samples present mainly negative scores and 6B samples positives scores, indicating that the chemical changes diagnostic of burning (hydroxyl substitutions and cyanamide formation) are more intense in samples classified as m-Stiner grade 6A than in samples classified as 6B, pointing again towards the inversion of the structural changes in bone with heating. For PC3C most samples present positive loadings, but samples Tyr024, Tyr025, Tyr026, Tyr029 Tyr045, Tyr051, Tyr073 and Tyr099 present high negative loadings, indicating that those samples are less crystalline than the rest. For PC4C, most samples present positive scores except for Tyr011, Tyr014, Tyr040, Tyr055, Tyr068, Tyr071, Tyr073, and Tyr084, all of them are samples from hand/foot, except for a patella and a long bone fragment (see Fig. 12). This component indicates cyanamide formation, which points towards a relation between bone type and the presence of this compound. For PC5C samples Tyr018, Tyr026, Tyr036 present considerably higher positive loadings than the rest, and Tyr020, Tyr024 and Tyr029 present higher negative loadings than the other samples, indicating that the OH− substitutions of A-type carbonate were not as extensive in the former compared with the latter. For PC6C half of the samples present positive loadings, and this seems to respond to a distribution pattern: samples from layers S3 and ÖB show mainly negative loadings and samples from Badger layer seem to have mainly positive loadings for this component. The band at ca. 1086 cm− 1 involved in this component is characteristic of calcined samples, but it has not been thoroughly studied yet, and we discuss it below.
4.4. Transformation of bone with temperature: shift between m-Stiner grades 3 and 4.
In this study, we observed that the differences in the spectroscopical signal between calcined samples and non-calcined samples are larger than the ones among samples within those groups, even between different m-Stiner burning grades. This differentiation was already somewhat observed by Gallo et al. (2021) who found that IRSF allowed to distinguish between calcined and not calcined samples. This shift in bone structure between 400ºC and 700ºC was also observed in previous studies (Etok et al. 2007; Galeano and García-Lorenzo 2014) in which cremated bone samples were analysed by XRD, showing an increase in crystals size. Gonçalvez et al. (2018) also found substantial changes in IRSF, BPI and OH/P between 700–800°C. These authors found that IRSF keeps slightly increasing after 800ºC. However, other authors (Thompson et al. 2013; Snoeck et al. 2014a; Ellingham et al. 2016), have described a slight decrease of IRSF values (and thereby crystallinity) with temperature after reaching 700–800°C. This is also shown in our case, since IRSF values (as well as the general slight change of trend observed in other MIR-indices) are lower for m-Stiner grade 6B than grade 6A samples. Ellingham et al. (2016) attributed the decrease in crystallinity (and decrease in C/C, PHT, increase in CO3/P, CO/CO3) to the sintering process, and formation of β-TCP.
Those abrupt changes in crystallinity were also observed by Greiner et al. (2019), who attributed them to the loss of organics that no longer coat the apatite crystals, allowing their growth. The strong shift in the indices’ values - and the separation in two groups of samples based on their IR-spectroscopic signals - seems to respond to the complete elimination of organic contents which leaves the inorganic part exposed and, therefore, changes in its structure occur (Person et al. 1996; Thompson et al. 2013). These structural changes give the calcined bone completely different properties than bones that underwent diagenesis or low temperature exposure (Lebon et al. 2010). At which temperature this change occurs is not clear yet. According to Etok et al. (2007), proteins are removed at temperatures of 400°C while other organic components (such as aromatic compounds) are still present up to 600°C; although, Gallo et al. (2023) observed that this can occur under lower temperatures at long-exposure times. However, in our case, the aromatic signal was only present in Tyr076 as a subtle shoulder. This sample is a dog carpus classified as m-Stiner grade 6A. Also, some of the organics’ absorbances are shown in most of the samples, even in some of the samples classified as 6A and 6B, in which a slight absorbance at the amides I and II regions is observed. However, some samples lack organics completely, especially those from the 6A grade. This agrees with the findings of Mamede et al. (2018b), as they did not observe a complete loss of organics until temperatures higher than 700°C, but they attributed this phenomenon not only to the temperatures reached but also to the duration of burning.
In addition to the removal of organic compounds, carbonate ions substitutions are also involved in the increase of apatite crystallinity. This is shown in our samples by the negative correlation between IRSF and C/P, and BPI, but positive correlation with C/C. This was documented in previous studies (Snoeck et al. 2014b; Végh et al. 2022) and indicates that crystallinity increases as carbonate content relative to phosphate decreases (loss of carbonate ions). However, in our study, the C/C, i.e., A-type carbonate substitutions relative to B-type carbonate substitution, tends to increase with temperature once calcination is reached, even though the overall amount of carbonate decreases, in agreement with previous studies (Snoeck et al. 2014a; Gonçalves et al. 2018; Brandao et al. 2023). Marques et al. (2018) stated that B-type carbonate is more sensitive to heat than A-type carbonate and starts to decrease earlier, which is coherent with our results, since C/C increases from m-Stiner grade 4 onwards. Another factor to consider is the substitution of some hydroxyl groups by carbonate A-type at high burning temperatures (Zazzo et al. 2012; Thompson et al. 2013). However, care must be taken when interpreting C/C changes, since this index also reflects the presence of lipidic signal at 1450 cm− 1 in bones burnt under temperatures of 800°C (Gonçalves et al. 2018). These organic compounds are the first in disappearing with temperature (Marques et al. 2018), thereby, it is possible that the initial decrease of this index from m-Stiner grades 0 to 3 may also reflect the loss of lipidic content. We have also observed that some of the samples of m-Stiner grade 4 onwards, present a double peak at ν2CO3−2 region (872 cm− 1 and 879 cm− 1), and part of the highly calcined samples had even completely lost the band at 872 cm− 1. This phenomenon has been attributed to A-type substitution of the OH− group and has been described to occur at temperatures higher than 700°C (Fleet 2009; Thompson et al. 2013; Thompson et al. 2013; Greiner et al. 2019) (see. Figure 13). Thus, we think that during calcination, global carbonate content decreases, but some A-type carbonate substitutes in OH− sites of the hydroxyapatite, resulting in an increase of the C/C index (more A-type carbonate relative to B-type carbonate) and the appearance of the ~ 879 cm− 1 band. This may be due to a secondary carbonate formation from the CO2 released during cremation (Hüls et al. 2010; Gonçalves et al. 2018; Brandao et al. 2023).
The bands at 3570 and 630 cm− 1, which have been suggested as indicators of calcination (e.g., Gallo et al. 2023), appear because of the loss of A-type carbonate ions and its substitution by hydroxyl ions (OH−) (Etok et al. 2007; Snoeck et al. 2014a; Mamede et al. 2018a; Shaw 2022). This is coherent with the negative correlation between PHT versus BPI and C/P observed in our samples. Shaw (2022) found that, at least for faunal remains, the 630 cm− 1 band never appears at temperatures under 525–537°C even during long-exposure times. In our samples, PHT is positively correlated to IRSF, which indicates an increase of the OH− libration band with crystallinity, which according to Snoeck et al. (2014b) is due to the fact that hydroxyl ions are smaller than carbonate ions, allowing for the apatite structure to get more crystallized. PHT is also positively correlated to TPV, which we also attributed to an increase in crystallinity, and we discussed it below.
Among the calculated MIR-indices, OH/P, CO/CO3 and FWHM do not respond to the abrupt increase/decrease pattern from m-Stiner grade 3 to grade 4. FWHM, in particular, does not seem to respond to temperature changes in our samples, disagreeing with previous studies. For example, Thompson et al. (2013) observed that FWHM decreased with temperature until the 800ºC, but when reached, it grew again, although not as much as in unburned bone.
4.5. Transformation with temperature: formation of new bands: 2012, 1088, 961, 699 cm− 1
Some new absorbance bands are shown in the spectrum of bones at ~ 2012 and 699 cm− 1 (cyanamide) and at 1088 and 961 cm− 1 (ν1,3 PO3 2−) over temperature.
4.5.1. ν1,3 PO3 2− bands (1088, 961 cm− 1)
Both bands have been shown to appear and sharpen with increasing m-Stiner grades. In particular, the band at 961 cm− 1 has been found to also appear and sharpen in inhumated bone subjected to severe diagenesis (see for example spectra in Lebon et al. (2016) and Castorina et al. (2023)). This goes in accordance with Querido et al. (2018), who observed that absorbance at 960 cm− 1 is correlated to the crystallinity of biological and synthetic apatites. The index proposed here, TPV, is positively correlated with IRSF. This may indicate a relation between the sharpening of 1088 cm− 1 with the increase in crystallinity of the bioapatite. Also, TPV is positively correlated with PHT and negatively correlated with BPI. In addition, the PCAC, suggest that this band covariates positively with OH− (630 and 3572 cm− 1) and negatively with amide II (see Supplementary Table 6). Thus, it is possible that the loss of carbonate ions and their substitution by hydroxyl anions plays a role in the sharpening of 1088 cm− 1 peak. Despite this, Reidsma et al. (2016) found this band as a subtle shoulder in samples heated at 900°C under reducing conditions, thereby, the incorporation of hydroxyl ions may not be the cause of its appearance, or perhaps other factors are involved in its formation. The TPV index starts increasing at samples classified as m-Stiner grade 4 (samples start to get calcined), and keeps increasing at grade 5, grade 6A and then decreases slightly at grade 6B (see supplementary Fig. 3). This indicates that the TPV is a promising index for inferring bone temperature, and it would be interesting to explore it in experimental studies. This agrees with Gallo et al. (2023), who used the presence/absence of the 1088 cm− 1 band as a proxy of temperature transformations, in particular calcination. Some authors (Marques et al. 2018; Festa et al. 2019) consider 1088 cm− 1 band as indicative of the transformation of the mineral lattice into fluorapatite (francolite; Ca5(PO4)3F). In agreement with this hypothesis, previous studies (Geiger and Weiner 1993; Trueman et al. 2008) have described higher 603 cm− 1 intensities when F− substitutes in the OH− sites of the bioapatite. This phenomenon would increase the IRSF values and therefore would explain the correlation between this index and the 1088 cm− 1 peak. Also, in our samples, a higher absorbance of 599 cm− 1 relative to 560 cm− 1 is observed and is consistent with the PCAC results in which 560 cm− 1 band is grouped in PC1C with 1023 cm− 1 band, but the band at 599 cm− 1 is grouped in PC3C with 3572 cm− 1 band (hydroxyls, thus it is temperature-related). Marques et al. (2018) explain the absence of the 1088 cm− 1 band at low temperatures as being obscured by the main ν3PO43− band, which would become narrower at higher temperatures. However, we have not observed any tendency for the broadening of this band with temperature and the TPV index does not correlate with FWHM (Fig. 7). Festa et al. (2019) also interpreted the band at ~ 961 cm− 1, together with ~ 1086 cm− 1, to be indicative of fluorapatite. However, in our samples, these two bands are not grouped in the same PC in the PCAC (i.e., they do not covary). Lebon et al. (2010) observed that archaeological samples present Sr+ 2 and F− intakes. However, they noticed that calcined samples did not have a highly altered elemental composition, and we observe in our samples that the band at ~ 1088 cm− 1 sharpens with increasing temperature (as observed by Berna 2010), which means that F− incorporation is probably not the cause (or at least not the main one) for the presence and sharpening of this band. In addition, Stathopoulou et al. (2008), analysing mammal fossil bones, found that diagenesis can also produce and shape this band, it did not correlate with F− concentration - supporting our hypothesis. The study of the elemental composition would shed some light on the relation between the presence of this band and the formation of fluorapatite.
4.5.2. Cyanamide formation
In some Tyresta samples of the calcined group, bands characteristic of cyanamide (2012, 699 cm-1) were detected. The cause for the formation of this compound is still under debate. Some authors have argued that it may be related to the presence/absence of oxygen during the burning process (Gonçalves et al. 2023). Reidsma et al. (2016) observed that bone heated at temperatures higher than 700°C, in anaerobic conditions, tends towards the formation of cyanamide, and Gonçalves et al. (2023) noticed that this peak’s intensity increases with temperature. One of Gonçalves et al. (2023) criteria for recognizing bones burnt under anaerobic conditions is dark colour. In our samples, L* is indeed negatively correlated with the cyanamide bands, indicating that low lightness is related to the presence of this compound. Furthermore, a* and b* are also negatively correlated to this band, indicating that a bluer-greener coloration of the bones would be related with anaerobic burning environment. Note also that using naked-eye colour for inferring temperature can lead to biases, since blackish colouring may have its origin in reducing-environment conditions instead of low-temperature heating (Reidsma et al. 2016). The anaerobic conditions hypothesis is consistent with our PCAC results, in which PC3C and PC4C represent OH- vs. cyanamide substitutions (3572 vs. 699 cm-1 and 630 vs. 2012 cm-1, respectively). Being those facts indicative of N-C ≡ N bending substituting at 3570 cm-1 (OH- stretching) and C ≡ N stretching substituting for 630 cm-1 (OH- libration) and would also explain why Gonçalves et al. (2023) found cyanamide absorbance in samples in which the peak at 3570 cm-1 band (OH- stretching) was also observable, while Reidsma et al. (2016) did not. Thus, both PC3C and PC4C are likely to be related with oxygen availability in the burning environment: samples with positive values would indicate aerobic environments and samples with negative scores for these PCs would indicate anaerobic burning.
In our samples, even though the PCAC showed that 2012 cm− 1 anti-covaries with 630 cm− 1 and 699 cm− 1 anti-covaries with 3570 cm− 1, the four bands are present at the same time in the spectra. This has already been shown in previous studies (Zazzo et al. 2013; Snoeck et al. 2014a), and points to a different explanation other than the reduction/oxidation environment of the combustion process. Leskovar et al. (2025) observed that the time of exposure to heating had an impact on the 2012 cm− 1 band. These authors found that at temperatures of 900°C the intensity of the 2012 cm− 1 band decreased with higher exposure times, while the 630 cm− 1 and the A-type carbonate increased. This could explain the differences of CN/P index in our samples according to bone type, since cyanamide is higher in samples with thin, soft tissue (carpal/tarsal bones, patella) while OH− is higher in thoracic bones, that are surrounded by fat and other soft tissues. We hypothesize that the fat may have played a role as fuel (animal fats were used as fuel for firing lamps since at least Iron Age (Mayyas et al. 2017) and they are still used for biodiesel synthesis (Awad et al. 2014; Kumar et al. 2006)), increasing the burning time at these regions, and therefore leading to the substitutions of carbonate by hydroxyl groups rather than cyanamide. This fuel effect was also demonstrated by the experiment of Dehaan (2012), who burned three human corpses under different conditions and observed that subcutaneous body fat acted as fuel for fire leading to the torso, pelvis and upper legs to burn for longer times than hands, feet, head and lower legs. We assume that, in Tyresta, once started the fire was not manipulated until extinguished, following its natural firing patterns of shorter times of firing in hands and feet and much longer for the torso due to the role of fat as fuel.
Cyanamide has been also associated to the presence/absence of ammonia during the cremation process (Mamede et al. 2018a; Gonçalves et al. 2018). In this case, the absence of surrounding flesh of hand/feet, as well as patella, may have created the proper environment for the formation of this compound (perhaps due to presence/absence of organic matter). Some authors have proposed the combustion fuel (higher N content in flesh than in wood) as the origin of the ammonia that leads to the substitution of hydroxyl and A-type carbonates for C2NH (Snoeck et al. 2014a). According to Zazzo et al. (2013), the carbon may come from the collagen of the burnt bone or from the wood of the pyre. Another possible explanation is the presence/absence of clothing which can be a source of ammonia (i.e., leather shoes or clothes), and it can as well contribute to creating a more reducing environment, allowing the formation of cyanamide (Salesse et al. 2021). However, this is unlikely to be our case, since our samples belong both to human and animal bones. Also, Salesse et al. (2021) only analysed foot bones, which precludes differences among bone types, meaning that perhaps the presence of cyanamide is explained by time of exposure rather than the presence or absence of shoes.
Another possible explanation is the pugilistic posture - i.e., contraction of the muscles with fire resulting in a characteristic posture with flexed arms, legs and wrists (Symes et al. 2015). - in which both the bones from hand and feet as well as patellae are highly exposed, and they are the first to burn (Symes et al. 2015). However, recent investigations have proposed that the pugilistic posture is not a universal phenomenon when studied in real fire settings instead of crematorium chambers, and sometimes the body reaction to burning is the extension of the limbs away from the torso (Harding et al. 2024). Also, some of the bones that show this band belong to horse and dog, so perhaps even if they got the pugilistic posture, the areas exposed to fire would be different compared to those of humans because of the anatomy of these animals and, again, this does not seem the most likely explanation.
4.6. Bone type and species
In the non-calcined group, no statistically significant differences were found between different bone types. However, structural and chemical differences among bone types have been described before in the literature (Gonçalves et al. 2018; Leskovar et al. 2023; Maurer et al. 2023; Colmenares-Prado et al. 2025). The relatively small number of samples of this group (n = 23) and the fact that there were bones from three different species (human, horse and dog), prevented a proper statistical analysis of this group, and we assume that the differences between species may be larger than differences between skeletal elements.
However, in the calcined group (n = 84), we observed that OH/P and PHT are higher in thoracic bones compared with crania and hands/feet. Those two indices were described to indicate oxygen availability during the burning process (Gonçalves et al. 2023). Thereby, this likely means that thoracic bones were burned under aerobic conditions. On the other hand, CN/P is higher in hands/feet than in crania. PC4C scores are considerably more negative (i.e., cyanamide signal) for hand/foot bones and patellae and a higher number of samples with positive scores (hydroxyl) in thoracic bones compared with the other bone types. This is consistent with Stamataki et al. (2021), who observed that cyanamide (evaluated by the CN/P index) was more abundant in long bones than in ribs.
Thereby, it seems that the differences in bone structure in our samples are more related with burning patterns than with ante-mortem pre-existent differences. This agrees with Krap et al. (2019) that found that ante-mortem differences in colour (measured in CIELab system) of burnt bone among bone type, age, or sex, disappeared at temperatures above 300°C. Since we found that colour and chemical composition are highly related, it is likely that structure-chemical differences disappear with increasing temperature. Spectroscopic differences among bone types were also not observed in previous investigations on cremated bones (Mamede et al. 2018b), or statistical differences were only found for one index (CN/P, Stamataki et al. 2021).
Regarding species, in the literature there are some examples of chemical differences in spectral properties between human and non-humans in inhumated bones (Wang et al. 2019; Martínez Cortizas and López-Costas 2024). We observed statistically significant differences in IRSF between species in the non-calcined group, but not in the calcined group, which might indicate that the changes of bone (i.e., recrystallization) with temperature are stronger than the ante-mortem structural differences among species. Thereby, despite of being tempting to use spectroscopic data to distinguish animal from human bones in the context of a highly fragmented cremation burial, care must be taken when using MIR-indices to discriminate among species in calcined bones.
4.7. Variations with time of exposure
Hiller et al. (2003) observed that hydroxyapatite crystals’ shape and size changed not only with temperature but also with heating time. Recent experimental studies have also focused on the effect of time of exposure to heat (e.g., Mamede et al. 2018b; Legan et al. 2020; Gallo et al. 2023), and the general findings suggest that some changes in bone structure/composition are related to the time of exposure while others are necessarily triggered by temperature. Snoeck et al. (2014a) found that MIR-indices change with heating time until the bone is fully calcined, but once this happens, significant changes are only observed with temperature. If this was the case for the Tyresta samples, changes in the calcined group would be reflecting time variations in exposure to heating.
Both Gallo et al. (2023) and Leskovar et al. (2025) studies found that at 300°C there is a sudden loss of collagen, that keeps decreasing with time of exposure at this temperature. Carbonate loss also started at this temperature, but it did not increase with time of exposure to this temperature. However, Gallo et al. (2023) observed that IRSF did not change with time at 300°C. This would imply that the loss of organics itself is not enough for the mineral changes to occur with heating. Leskovar et al. (2025) observed that OH− ions could incorporate at the bioapatite lattice even at 300°C with long exposure times, while Gallo et al. (2023) did not observe any OH− libration absorbance at this temperature. In addition, Leskovar et al. (2025) found that the presence of the 879 cm− 1 A-type carbonate band at these temperatures even at short exposure times, which increased as 872 cm− 1 B-type carbonate decreased. At 600°C the amide I kept decreasing with exposure until its complete disappearance. Also, at this temperature carbonate decreased and OH− increased with exposure time, while IRSF and the 961 cm− 1 band continued increasing with a sharp change at 90 and 120 minutes. Gallo et al. (2023) found that at 550°C and 750°C the IRSF increased with time (9 hours). However, after 48 hours at 550°C IRSF, PHT and the sharpening of 1090 cm− 1 band kept increasing but at 750°C IRSF suffered a decrease with heating time. Leskovar et al. (2025) only observed this decrease at long-time exposure at 900°C and higher temperatures (i.e., 1200°C). Leskovar et al. (2025) noticed that at 900°C the amide I, 1415 cm− 1, and 872 cm− 1 bands disappeared almost completely while the 878 cm− 1 and OH− bands increased at long-time exposure times. At 1200°C all the organics and carbonates (including the 878 cm− 1 band) disappeared. But they detected that at short heating times at 1200°C cyanamide and the 878 cm− 1 peak can sometimes be present. According to Leskovar et al. (2025), at 1200°C OH− remained unchanged respect to 900°C. In our case, there is a good correlation between indices at the different m-Stiner grades. Thus, it seems that chemical changes are mainly explained by temperature rather than time of exposure to heating (indicating that probably the time of heating was relatively short). According to Carrol and Smith (2018), prolonged fires need human intervention to avoid extinction, therefore, it is likely that in the Tyresta site, once the fire was started, no effort was made on maintaining it alive, leaving it to follow its own course.
4.8. Archaeological implications in Tyresta site
Temperatures reached. Some of the samples studied here reached the calcination state. Also, no signs of long-term exposure are found, thereby, the calcination probably occurred at ~ 700ºC (Gallo et al. 2021; Gallo et al. 2023). Also, part of our samples reached the china-like appearance characteristic of m-Stiner grade 6B. In addition, the spectroscopic signal indicates that the samples did not reach 900–1000ºC, since carbonate loss was not complete (Mamede et al. 2018a; Gallo et al. 2021). This is also supported by the fact that bands involved in the CO/CO3 index are present in our samples, in agreement with Thompson et al. (2009) findings.
Funerary practices. Our results point to the fact that once the fire was initiated, no more human intervention happened until it was completely consumed. This is inferred from the presence of cyanamide in hand/feet bone samples, since the natural pattern for these types of bones is to burn more rapidly than torso bones (Dehaan 2012).
Badger layer. We have observed a trend towards higher 1088 cm− 1 towards 961 cm− 1 band in badger layer in respect to ÖB and S3. This, combined with the fact that samples from this layer were visually different, suggests that the samples come from another burning event, since the band at 1086 cm− 1 is temperature-specific. Also, the OH/P index is significantly higher for the badger layer compared with layers S2 and S3, indicating that samples from this layer were subjected to higher temperatures. This is not surprising, since most bone fragments from this layer were classified as m-Stiner grade 6. This layer is named after the first archaeological hypothesis that a badger made a tunnel and removed samples from inside the pyre. However, the differences of the temperature achieved point to a different explanation of the existence of this layer, maybe it was intentional and human-crafted. It would be interesting to radiocarbon-date samples from this layer and from inside the cairn to check whether the ages of the bones of the different layers are consistent or not. Also, the statistically higher values of Am/P and CO/CO3 indices in bones of the badger layer versus S3 (both indices) and S2 (CO/CO3), points to a higher protein content. This may point towards a different origin of these bones. However, as indicated before, most pre-burning structural and chemical differences between bones, even at species level, get loss after calcination, so this result must be taken with care.
Mercury. Although not extensively documented, there are some studies describing the use of mercury during the Viking age, like the mercury gilded brooches found at the proto-urban Birka site (Sweden) (Ullén et al. 2021) or the high mercury concentrations in stone artefacts identified as possible touchstones for metal amalgamation in the Viking age burials of Hedeby (Germany) (Ježek and Holub 2014). The gilding process was dangerous for the workers, because mercury vapours were released by the heating of gold and mercury alloys (Ullén et al. 2021). Those practices would lead to mercury intoxication during life, producing high levels of mercury in human bones – however, once manufactured those objects were used by people, a practice that could have increased the mercury exposition in life without being extremely hazardous for the person. The concentrations found in Tyresta for the human bones (1.55–63.29 ng∙g− 1) are similar to those found in control or low-exposure populations (see Álvarez-Fernández et al. 2020). It is difficult to know the amount of mercury released during cremation, but if it was not significant, the observed values would be in line with moderate-to-low environmental metal pollution as the ones observed in post-Roman Lanzada (López-Costas et al. 2020). However, since mercury is volatile at high temperatures, we hypothesize that the post-mortem concentration before cremation could be higher. At least, despite being cremated, it is higher in human bones than in the unburnt animal bones, suggesting other source rather than the environmental that was described as the primary one in A Lanzada.