Our study is, to our knowledge, the largest tick microbiome study to date based on next-generation sequencing of the 16S rRNA bacterial gene, with a robust sample size of 259 independent bacterial communities associated with Amblyomma americanum sampled from six natural sites in two distant regions of the species range and from one laboratory-reared colony. Additionally, it is also the first study that focuses on evaluating both sexual and regional differences in the microbiome and functional metagenome of A. americanum, particularly in areas of recent range expansion.
Geographic region and sex strongly influence alpha and beta diversity
We found that both geographic region and sex strongly influence alpha and beta diversity of the lone star tick microbiome. This was the case whether we analyzed alpha diversity by ASV richness or Shannon diversity index, and whether we analyzed beta diversity by weighted or unweighted UniFrac distances (Figs. 2–3, Supplementary Figures S2-S3). Interestingly, we observed higher alpha diversity in the western region than in the northern region. We also observed significant differences in alpha diversity among the three western sites separated by 194–229 km and among the three northern sites separated by 63–107 km. This finding shows that the external ecological context of a site influences the tick’s internal microbiome. For example, Allaire State Park (ASP) is only 63 km from Bass River State Forest (BRSF); yet, the microbiome of ticks in ASP which is characterized by a combination of mixed and deciduous forest differs significantly from the microbiome of ticks in BRSF which is characterized by pine barrens [2]. Several studies also found that geographic region and sex are significant predictors of alpha and beta diversity of tick microbiomes [30–32, 52]. However, Chicana et al. examined the microbiomes of three species of ticks in the western United States - Ixodes pacificus, Dermacentor albipictus, and Dermacentor occidentalis - and detected no significant geographic variation in microbial richness, diversity, or composition between ticks collected from two sites located approximately 64 km apart [15].
We observed that males uniformly had higher microbiome diversity than females at all natural sites, but not at the colony. These results concur with various other studies that found higher microbiome alpha diversity in male ticks of various ixodid genera including Amblyomma [52–55], Dermacentor [30, 31], Ixodes [32, 55–57], Rhipicephalus [58, 59], Haemaphysalis [60], and Hyalomma [61]. Thus, the pattern of males harboring more diverse microbiomes than females is widespread among tick taxa.
Host environmental filtering governs bacterial community assembly, particularly in female ticks
Observed values of NTI and NRI, metrics of phylogenetic alpha diversity were positive across all 259 ticks, indicating consistent phylogenetic clustering of bacterial communities relative to null expectations (Fig. 3B and Supplementary Figure S3B). This means that the microbial taxa within each tick tend to be more closely related than expected by chance. Bacterial community assembly is thus not driven by competition among species but by environmental filtering [46, 62]. In other words, tick physiology or vertical transmission of endosymbionts allows only certain closely related taxa with certain phenotypes or functions to inhabit the tick’s internal environment. Couper et al. analyzed co-occurrence patterns of taxa in the microbiome of Ixodes pacificus and inferred that characteristics of the tick’s internal environment, such as pH and concentrations of essential nutrients, create favorable conditions for certain microbes [14]. It is likely that characteristics of the lone star tick’s internal environment filter which species can establish as stable members of the microbiome, but this merits further investigation.
The sex-based differences highlighted above are further demonstrated by analyses of NTI and NRI. NTI, which emphasizes terminal (tip-level) clustering, was significantly positive for all females and for the majority of males, suggesting that closely related bacterial taxa inhabit individual ticks, especially in females. NRI, which captures deeper phylogenetic relationships, was also significantly positive in most ticks, further supporting the inference of phylogenetic conservatism in microbiome assembly. The higher rate of significant phylogenetic clustering in females reflects more stable bacterial communities. Conversely, the lower rate of clustering in males reflects more variable or transient bacterial communities. These findings suggest sex-specific differences in the determinism and phylogenetic structure of tick microbiomes, with females showing stronger and more consistent patterns, possibly due to more stable associations with endosymbionts or differences in feeding behaviors and reproductive roles.
Geographic region and sex strongly influence relative abundance of specific taxa
We found Coxiella to be very abundant and dominant over all other bacterial genera (Fig. 4A). This finding is consistent with other studies that found Coxiella as the predominant endosymbiont of A. americanum [54, 63]. Not only was Coxiella highly abundant, it was also highly prevalent, detected in all ticks in the colony, all ticks in the western region, and all but 7 male ticks in the northern region. Thus, we found Coxiella in all laboratory-reared and field-collected A. americanum females and most field-collected males, consistent with the first report showing evidence that Coxiella may be an obligate endosymbiont [64].
Only male ticks had bacterial taxa that are differentially abundant between regions (Fig. 4B); female ticks had no taxa that are differentially abundant between regions. This novel finding further supports our earlier conclusion that the external environment (e.g. vertebrate hosts, soil, vegetation) affects the composition and relative abundance of male microbiomes, and that female microbiomes are more stable. The LEfSe analysis found a higher number of overabundant taxa in western sites than in northern sites (Fig. 4E). Interestingly, Coxiella is not one of these taxa identified in the regional LEfSe analysis. Since the LEfSe analysis investigated regional differences while controlling for the effect of sex, it identified taxa whose differential abundance in a region is consistent in both males and females. Hence, the overabundance of Coxiella in OK and the five taxa overabundant in NY/NJ identified in the MaAsLin2 regional analysis (Fig. 4B) are only differentially abundant in male ticks and not in female ticks. Additionally, our MaAsLin2 analyses excluded rare genera present in less than 10% of samples, while Lefse analyses did not; ten genera included in the LEfSe (e.g. Borrelia) are below that threshold. Together these MaAsLin2 and LEfSe analyses describe the regional differences in microbiome identified by the beta diversity analysis and concur with other tick microbiome studies which found a significant effect of region [31, 32, 52, 65]. However, no study to date has documented the interaction between sex and region described above.
In both regions of range expansion, Coxiella was the only genus overly overabundant in female ticks; male ticks featured a higher number of overly abundant taxa (Fig. 4C-D), consistent with the finding that males have higher alpha diversity than female ticks (Fig. 3A and Supplemental Fig. 3A). Only two of the seven taxa (Mycobacterium and Methylobacterium) identified as overabundant in northern males were also identified as overabundant in western males, suggesting that while Mycobacterium and Methylobacterium may be uniquely suited to fill the space left by a reduced dominance of Coxiella in males, regional differences in microbiota also contribute to which other bacteria become abundant in males. For example, Rickettsia was the most differentially abundant genus only in northern males. Williams-Newkirk et al. also found that males contain more Rickettsia and females contain more Coxiella [54]. The LEfSe analysis investigating sex-based differences in wild ticks while controlling for the effect of region largely corroborates MaAsLin2 results, showing a high number of taxa overabundant in males and the overabundance of Coxiella in females (Fig. 4F). This sex-based pattern of Coxiella abundance is entirely absent in the colony ticks.
Distinct taxonomic profiles of the microbiome lead to distinct functional profiles between the sexes
In analyses comparing males and females in both northern and western regions, males had a higher number of differentially abundant pathway groups, indicating that males possess a more functionally diverse microbiome. This mirrors the taxonomic patterns between sexes, the higher functional diversity in males being a product of higher microbial diversity. Further, the colony ticks showed few differentially abundant metabolic pathways between males and females, reflecting their similar taxonomic profiles and indicating that the artificial conditions of the laboratory-reared colony alter microbial functions observed in wild ticks.
Obligate blood-feeders like ticks are challenged with a hyper-specialized diet lacking in key nutrients such as carbohydrates, lipids, and vitamins [66]. B vitamins are largely absent in a blood-based diet and ticks are incapable of synthesizing them de novo. However, ticks counteract this nutritional deficiency by forming close associations with vitamin-synthesizing bacteria. Coxiella-like endosymbionts (CLEs) are the most widespread vitamin B-producing endosymbiont in ticks, being associated with approximately two-thirds of tick species [66]. These endosymbionts typically dominate the microbiomes of their hosts and have been shown to be crucial for tick fitness at all life stages in multiple species [64, 67–69]. CLEs in A. americanum possess complete or partial metabolic pathways for the biosynthesis of B vitamins [11, 70].
We found four vitamin pathways are abundant in females and four in males (Fig. 5). This pattern was consistent in both regions, suggesting sex-based vitamin requirements regardless of external environment. The four pathways abundant in females are for the biosynthesis of vitamins B1, B2, B3, and B5, all of which are pathways linked to the Coxiella symbiont [70], which is abundant in female ticks (Fig. 4F). The four pathways abundant in males are for the biosynthesis of vitamins B6, B7, and B12 and the degradation of vitamin C; only two of these vitamins (B6 and B7) are attributed to Coxiella [70]. The higher number of Coxiella-associated pathways in female ticks suggests that females depend on Coxiella more than males. Other studies have found higher abundances of endosymbionts in ovaries than in testes and demonstrated that elimination of key endosymbionts impairs tick development to a higher degree in females than in males [68, 71].
Ticks also lack the ability to synthesize or degrade heme, despite it being both necessary for important functions, such as oxidative phosphorylation, and toxic in excess quantities due to its reactivity and role in inducing oxidative stress [72]. After hard ticks engorge themselves with blood and digest the hemoglobin therein, they must contend with an overabundance of free heme, which is cytotoxic. We did not identify heme degradation pathways in any bacteria in our study, suggesting that lone star ticks manage heme using other means that do not include microbes, such as sequestering it in hemosomes or with heme-binding proteins [73]. However, we identified six pathways related to heme biosynthesis and the pathway group was ubiquitous across our study. The heme biosynthesis pathway group was more abundant in females in both regions of wild ticks, but was not differentially abundant in colony females. Although ticks generally acquire heme in copious amounts directly from the bloodmeal, the differential abundance of heme biosynthesis pathways in wild females suggests that bacteria play a role in heme metabolism and potentially supplement their hosts with this essential cofactor [66]. This phenomenon may be affected by laboratory conditions which reduce sex-based differences in the microbiome of colony ticks.
Geographic region and sex influence pathogen prevalence
The number and abundance of pathogenic bacteria in any individual tick are actually small compared to the full diversity of bacterial species and their abundances. Although our sequencing data cannot discriminate between pathogenic and non-pathogenic species or strains of Borrelia and Rickettsia, we found significant regional and sex-based differences in the prevalence of these two genera. Most Borrelia present in the lone star tick are from the species B. lonestari. We detected Borrelia only in northern sites at low prevalence (7% in site BRSF, 13% in site ASP, and 9% in site CRSP). An early survey of B. lonestari across the range of lone star tick found low prevalence rates: 0% in OK, 0.42% in NY, and 9.1% in NJ [74]. In fact, 54 surveys involving more than 52,000 lone star ticks have revealed a low prevalence of B. lonestari and scarce B. burgdorferi [75]. A more recent survey detected B. lonestari in 6 out of 522 (1.1%) adult lone star ticks collected in OK [76].
Most Rickettsia present in the lone star tick are from the species R. amblyommatis. We detected Rickettsia ASVs at a higher prevalence in the northern region compared to the western region. Similarly, Mixson et al. reported higher prevalence of Rickettsia in adult A. americanum collected from NY/NJ sites (34.6%) compared to those collected from OK (11.8%) [74]. We also observed adult males were 2.66 times more likely to carry Rickettsia than adult females in OK. This is contrary to an early survey that found no significant differences in Rickettsia prevalence between male and female A. americanum ticks across its range [74], and also a recent survey that focused on ticks in OK [76]. The much higher prevalence of Rickettsia we observed in colony males compared to colony females merits further investigation.
Most Ehrlichia present in the lone star tick are from the species E. chaffeensis and E. ewingii. Our observed prevalences of Ehrlichia in field-collected populations (22.5% in the northern region and 21.2% in the western region) are the highest reported to date. The highest site prevalence was at LTSP with 14/40 (35%) ticks infected with Ehrlichia. Mixson et al. reported E. chaffeensis prevalences across 9 states ranging from 0–13.2%; only one local site out of 29 sampled sites had a prevalence of E. chaffeensis that exceeded 20% [74]. In the same study, Mixson et al. reported E. ewingii prevalences ranging from 0–18.6%. Overall, these findings highlight geographic hotspots or temporal outbursts that exacerbate Ehrlichia transmission pressure, warranting further research and surveillance.