Characteristics of the enrolled general adults and patients
In this study, we evaluated 23,036 general adults, identifying 1,220 as having SLD and 21,816 as not having SLD, using a questionnaire. Based on the CC, and after matching for age and sex (Supplemental Figure S1), we categorized subjects into five groups: CC-SLD- (n = 1,756), CC + SLD- (n = 8,900), MASLD (n = 890), MetALD (n = 262) and CC-SLD+ (n = 68). Additionally, 310 MASLD patients diagnosed by imaging or biopsy were included after the exclusion criteria (Supplemental Figure S2). The clinical characteristics showed significant differences across the five groups (Table 1). Most of the parameters, except for BUN were significantly higher in the CC + SLD-, MASLD and MetALD compared to the CC-SLD-. Notably, parameters, except for BP, platelet and creatinine, were significantly higher in MASLD than in CC + SLD-. The incidence of liver dysfunction (ALT > 33 for men, ALT > 25 for women) was 7.1% in CC-SLD-, 18.5% in CC + SLD-, 53.1% in MASLD (general adults), 36.2% in MetALD, 11.8% in CC-SLD+, and 79.4% in MASLD (patients). Additionally, hepatic steatosis index (HSI)(Lee et al. 2010) and fatty liver index (FLI)(Bedogni et al. 2006) were significantly elevated in MASLD and MetALD compared to CC + SLD-. Fibrosis-4 index (FIB-4)(Vallet-Pichard et al. 2007) was significantly higher in patients with MASLD compared to the general adults with MASLD. Furthermore, most of these parameters were worse in patients with MASLD compared to general adults with MASLD. The matching rates of OBE, GLC and TG in individuals meeting the CC were significantly higher in the MASLD and MetALD compared to CC + SLD- (Supplemental Figure S3). The matching rate of HT was significantly higher in MetALD compared to the other groups. These results indicate that the presence of steatosis with CC corresponds to a more aggravated metabolic status than in cases of CC positive without steatosis.
Table 1
Characteristics of the enrolled general adults and patients.
| | General adults | | | Patients |
| | CC-SLD- | | CC + SLD- | | MASLD | | | MetALD | | | CC-SLD+ | | | MASLD | |
| | (N = 1,756) | | (N = 8,900) | | (N = 890) | | | (N = 262) | | | (N = 68) | | | (N = 310) | |
| Sex (M/F) | 698 | / 1,058 | 3,610 | / 5,290 | | 361 | / 529 | | | 225 | / 37 | * | † | 32 | / 36 | | | 95 | / 215 | ‡ |
| Age | 60 | ± 10 | | 60 | ± 10 | | 60 | ± 10 | | | 60 | ± 10 | | | 59 | ± 12 | | | 59 | ± 15 | ‡ |
| BMI | 20 | ± 2 | * | 24 | ± 3 | † | 26 | ± 4 | * | † | 26 | ± 3 | * | † | 21 | ± 1 | * | | 27 | ± 5 | ‡ |
| Waist circumference (cm) | 75 | ± 6 | * | 86 | ± 9 | † | 91 | ± 9 | * | † | 91 | ± 8 | * | † | 79 | ± 5 | * | † | NA | | |
| BP (mmHg) | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
| Systolic | 120 | ± 14 | * | 130 | ± 17 | † | 130 | ± 15 | | † | 133 | ± 14 | | † | 121 | ± 16 | * | | NA | | |
| Diastolic | 72 | ± 8 | * | 79 | ± 11 | † | 79 | ± 10 | | † | 82 | ± 10 | * | † | 73 | ± 10 | * | | NA | | |
| Hemoglobin (g/dL) | 13.8 | ± 1.3 | * | 14.0 | ± 1.4 | † | 14.2 | ± 1.4 | * | † | 15.0 | ± 1.2 | * | † | 14.1 | ± 1.3 | | | 13.9 | ± 1.8 | |
| Platelet (10*4/µL) | 23 | ± 5 | * | 24 | ± 5 | † | 24 | ± 6 | | † | 22 | ± 5 | * | | 22 | ± 5 | * | | 21 | ± 11 | ‡ |
| FBG (mg/dL) | 84 | ± 7 | * | 93 | ± 20 | † | 95 | ± 21 | * | † | 101 | ± 27 | * | † | 86 | ± 7 | * | | 116 | ± 32 | ‡ |
| HbA1c (%) | 5.3 | ± 0.2 | * | 5.6 | ± 0.6 | † | 5.8 | ± 0.6 | * | † | 5.7 | ± 0.7 | | † | 5.3 | ± 0.2 | * | | 6.2 | ± 0.9 | ‡ |
| TG (mg/dL) | 79 | ± 27 | * | 122 | ± 90 | † | 144 | ± 84 | * | † | 165 | ± 122 | * | † | 83 | ± 25 | * | | 147 | ± 134 | |
| HDL cho (mg/dL) | 70 | ± 16 | * | 61 | ± 16 | † | 55 | ± 13 | * | † | 56 | ± 13 | * | † | 65 | ± 14 | | † | 51 | ± 15 | ‡ |
| LDL cho (mg/dL) | 124 | ± 28 | * | 127 | ± 32 | † | 126 | ± 32 | | | 117 | ± 31 | * | † | 124 | ± 26 | | | 115 | ± 32 | ‡ |
| AST (IU/L) | 23 | ± 9 | * | 24 | ± 10 | † | 29 | ± 15 | * | † | 30 | ± 17 | * | † | 23 | ± 5 | | | 56 | ± 49 | ‡ |
| ALT (IU/L) | 18 | ± 9 | * | 23 | ± 15 | † | 35 | ± 25 | * | † | 33 | ± 21 | * | † | 21 | ± 8 | | | 70 | ± 58 | ‡ |
| GGTP (IU/L) | 26 | ± 37 | * | 35 | ± 46 | † | 43 | ± 41 | * | † | 74 | ± 86 | * | † | 34 | ± 33 | | | 74 | ± 118 | ‡ |
| UA (mg/dL) | 4.9 | ± 1.2 | * | 5.2 | ± 1.3 | † | 5.5 | ± 1.2 | * | † | 6.1 | ± 1.4 | * | † | 4.9 | ± 1.3 | | | 6.0 | ± 1.5 | ‡ |
| BUN (mg/dL) | 15 | ± 4 | | 15 | ± 4 | | 15 | ± 4 | | | 15 | ± 4 | | | 14 | ± 3 | | | 14 | ± 5 | |
| Creatinin (mg/dL) | 0.70 | ± 0.23 | * | 0.70 | ± 0.20 | | 0.71 | ± 0.18 | | | 0.79 | ± 0.16 | * | † | 0.72 | ± 0.15 | | | 0.73 | ± 0.22 | |
| HSI | 28 | ± 2 | * | 33 | ± 5 | † | 37 | ± 6 | * | † | 35 | ± 5 | * | † | 30 | ± 3 | * | † | 40 | ± 7 | ‡ |
| FLI | 9 | ± 7 | * | 30 | ± 23 | † | 46 | ± 25 | * | † | 53 | ± 24 | * | † | 14 | ± 11 | * | | NA | | |
| FIB-4 | 1.54 | ± 0.65 | * | 1.38 | ± 0.60 | † | 1.35 | ± 0.63 | | † | 1.58 | ± 0.80 | * | | 1.45 | ± 0.62 | | | 2.46 | ± 1.78 | ‡ |
CC-SLD-: Cardiometabolic criteria negative and steatotic liver disease negative
CC+SLD-: Cardiometabolic criteria positive and steatotic liver disease negative
MASLD: metabolic dysfunction-associated steatotic liver disease
MetALD: metabolic dysfunction and alcohol-associated liver disease
CC-SLD+: Cardiometabolic criteria negative and steatotic liver disease positive
BMI: body mass index (weight (kg) / height2 (m2)).
BP: blood pressure
FBG: fasting blood glucose
TG: triglyceride
ALT: alanine aminotransferase
AST: aspartate aminotransferase
GGTP: gamma-glutamyl transpeptidase
UA: uric acid
HSI: hepatic steatosis index
FLI: fatty liver index
FIB-4: fibrosis 4 index
Values are mean ± s.d.
*<0.05 vs. CC+SLD-
†<0.05 vs. CC-SLD-
‡<0.05 MASLD (General adults vs patients)
The imbalances of FAAs observed in SLD and CC
We investigated the profiles of FAAs among five groups (Table 2). In MASLD, out of 20 FAAs, 15 FAAs; glutamic acid (Glu), proline (Pro), alanine (Ala), valine (Val), leucine (Leu), isoleucine (Ile), cystine (Cys), Met, Tyr, phenylalanine (Phe), ornithine (Orn), histidine (His), Lysine (Lys), tryptophan (Trp), and arginine (Arg) were significantly increased compared to CC-SLD-. Additionally, 12 FAAs; Glu, Pro, Ala, Val, Leu, Ile, Cys, Met. Tyr, Phe, Orn and Trp showed a significant increase in MASLD compared to CC + SLD-. Gly and asparagine (Asn) were significantly decreased, while Thr and Ser showed no change in MASLD compared to both CC-SLD- and CC + SLD- (Table 2). Similar changes were more pronounced in MetALD compared to MASLD (Fig. 1A). In CC-SLD+, Val and Leu were significantly increased compared to CC-SLD-.
Table 2
The imbalances of FAAs observed in SLD and CC.
| AAs | | CC-SLD- | | CC + SLD- | | MASLD | | | | MetALD | | | CC-SLD+ | | |
| (nmol/mL) | | (N = 1,756) | | (N = 8,900) | | (N = 890) | | | | (N = 262) | | | (N = 68) | | |
| Threonine | (Thr) | 183 | ± 38 | * | 187 | ± 40 | † | 185 | ± 40 | | | ‡ | 192 | ± 42 | | † | 186 | ± 45 | | |
| Serine | (Ser) | 93 | ± 14 | | 93 | ± 15 | | 93 | ± 16 | | | | 91 | ± 17 | | | 93 | ± 15 | | |
| Asparagine | (Asn) | 56 | ± 11 | | 56 | ± 12 | | 54 | ± 11 | * | † | ‡ | 56 | ± 11 | | | 54 | ± 11 | | |
| Glutamic acid | (Glu) | 46 | ± 12 | * | 56 | ± 16 | † | 63 | ± 17 | * | † | ‡ | 68 | ± 18 | * | † | 50 | ± 14 | * |
| Glutamine | (Gln) | 504 | ± 60 | * | 497 | ± 63 | † | 497 | ± 62 | | † | ‡ | 466 | ± 65 | * | † | 501 | ± 66 | | |
| Proline | (Pro) | 155 | ± 40 | * | 166 | ± 42 | † | 173 | ± 44 | * | † | ‡ | 183 | ± 37 | * | † | 160 | ± 40 | | |
| Glycine | (Gly) | 225 | ± 57 | * | 213 | ± 57 | † | 200 | ± 47 | * | † | ‡ | 186 | ± 39 | * | † | 220 | ± 54 | | |
| Alanine | (Ala) | 308 | ± 70 | * | 342 | ± 76 | † | 373 | ± 76 | * | † | | 379 | ± 68 | * | † | 330 | ± 81 | | |
| Valine | (Val) | 194 | ± 35 | * | 212 | ± 39 | † | 229 | ± 39 | * | † | | 232 | ± 37 | * | † | 207 | ± 36 | | † |
| Leucine | (Leu) | 109 | ± 21 | * | 118 | ± 24 | † | 125 | ± 23 | * | † | ‡ | 135 | ± 22 | * | † | 117 | ± 23 | | † |
| Isoleucine | (Ile) | 55 | ± 13 | * | 61 | ± 16 | † | 66 | ± 17 | * | † | ‡ | 69 | ± 15 | * | † | 59 | ± 14 | | |
| Cystine | (Cys) | 57 | ± 13 | * | 59 | ± 14 | † | 62 | ± 16 | * | † | ‡ | 68 | ± 16 | * | † | 55 | ± 15 | * |
| Methionine | (Met) | 26 | ± 4 | * | 27 | ± 4 | † | 28 | ± 4 | * | † | ‡ | 28 | ± 4 | * | † | 26 | ± 4 | | |
| Tyrosine | (Tyr) | 63 | ± 13 | * | 68 | ± 14 | † | 73 | ± 15 | * | † | ‡ | 76 | ± 15 | * | † | 65 | ± 13 | | |
| Phenylalanine | (Phe) | 59 | ± 10 | * | 62 | ± 10 | † | 64 | ± 10 | * | † | | 65 | ± 10 | * | † | 61 | ± 9 | | |
| Ornithine | (Orn) | 68 | ± 15 | * | 69 | ± 14 | † | 70 | ± 15 | | † | | 70 | ± 13 | | | 66 | ± 13 | | |
| Histidine | (His) | 83 | ± 10 | * | 85 | ± 11 | † | 85 | ± 11 | | † | ‡ | 89 | ± 12 | * | † | 85 | ± 12 | | |
| Lysine | (Lys) | 129 | ± 21 | * | 133 | ± 21 | † | 136 | ± 20 | * | † | ‡ | 139 | ± 18 | * | † | 129 | ± 22 | | |
| Tryptophan | (Trp) | 51 | ± 9 | * | 52 | ± 10 | † | 55 | ± 9 | * | † | ‡ | 56 | ± 10 | * | † | 51 | ± 10 | | |
| Arginine | (Arg) | 49 | ± 11 | * | 51 | ± 11 | † | 52 | ± 12 | | † | | 53 | ± 11 | | † | 50 | ± 11 | | |
| Total 20 AAs | | 2330 | ± 252 | * | 2419 | ± 270 | † | 2498 | ± 264 | * | † | | 2509 | ± 224 | * | † | 2380 | ± 265 | | |
AAs: amino acids
CC-SLD-: Cardiometabolic criteria negative and steatotic liver disease negative
CC+SLD-: Cardiometabolic criteria positive and steatotic liver disease negative
MASLD: metabolic dysfunction-associated steatotic liver disease
MetALD: metabolic dysfunction and alcohol-associated liver disease
CC-SLD+: Cardiometabolic criteria negative and steatotic liver disease positive
Values are mean ± SD.
*<0.05 vs. CC+SLD-
†<0.05 vs. CC-SLD-
‡<0.05 MASLD vs MetALD
Cardiometabolic criteria associated with the imbalance of FAAs
We confirmed that 3,948 out of 8,900 subjects with CC + SLD- met only one of the five CC. We categorized the 3,948 subjects into five groups: OBE (n = 2,249), GLC (n = 859), HT (n = 482), TG (n = 214) and HDL (n = 144) and investigated which CC were associated with change in FAAs. Hyperaminoacidemia was observed in the GLC, TG and the HDL, and changes in FAAs were similar among these groups (Table 3). Notably, in the GLC, all FAAs except for Gly were significantly increased compared to CC-SLD-. In the OBE and HT, the changes in FAAs were subtle and Ser, Asn, Gln, and Gly were significantly decreased in the OBE compared to CC-SLD-. FAAs changes were more pronounced with higher CC scores, with most FAAs increasing, especially in the presence of steatosis (Table 4). Similar trends were observed in MASLD patients as indicated by IR (Supplemental Table S3). Interestingly, while Thr levels were increased with CC score in CC + SLD-, this trend was not observed in MASLD. Moreover, in subject with CC score 4 and 5, the level was significantly lower in MASLD compared to CC + SLD- (Table 4). The levels of Gly and Gln gradually decreased with higher CC scores, regardless of steatosis, while the levels of Ser and Asn were unaffected by the CC score. Regarding the association between BW change and FAA levels (Table 5), a BW change of 2 percent did not significantly affect FAA levels except Cys in CC-SLD-. However, the BW change significantly changed the levels of some FAAs in CC + SLD- or MASLD. These changes were consistent with those observed by CC score (Table 4). In contrast, Ser and Gly levels significantly decreased in MASLD. Taken together, these findings suggest that a greater number of metabolic abnormalities are associated with increased levels of most FAAs, highlighting the underlying role of IR. However, some FAAs, particularly Gly, Ser and Thr, showed different change by steatosis.
Table 3
The imbalances of FAAs caused by both SLD and each distinct cardiometabolic criterion.
| | | | | | | Cardiometabolic criteria |
| AAs | CC-SLD- | CC-SLD+ | | OBE | | GLC | | HT | | TG | | HDL | |
| (nmol/mL) | (N = 1,756) | (N = 68) | | (N = 2,249) | | (N = 859) | | (N = 482) | | (N = 214) | | (N = 144) | |
| Thr | 183 | ± 38 | 186 | ± 45 | | 183 | ± 38 | | 188 | ± 40 | * | 186 | ± 39 | | 195 | ± 38 | * | 195 | ± 41 | * |
| Ser | 93 | ± 14 | 93 | ± 15 | | 92 | ± 14 | * | 97 | ± 16 | * | 94 | ± 15 | | 92 | ± 14 | | 96 | ± 16 | * |
| Asn | 56 | ± 11 | 54 | ± 11 | | 55 | ± 11 | * | 59 | ± 13 | * | 55 | ± 10 | * | 58 | ± 11 | | 59 | ± 11 | * |
| Glu | 46 | ± 12 | 50 | ± 14 | | 51 | ± 13 | * | 49 | ± 13 | * | 47 | ± 12 | * | 58 | ± 13 | * | 46 | ± 11 | |
| Gln | 504 | ± 60 | 501 | ± 66 | | 498 | ± 60 | * | 515 | ± 60 | * | 496 | ± 62 | * | 487 | ± 60 | * | 521 | ± 62 | * |
| Pro | 155 | ± 40 | 160 | ± 40 | | 156 | ± 37 | | 160 | ± 42 | * | 155 | ± 35 | | 184 | ± 37 | * | 166 | ± 37 | * |
| Gly | 225 | ± 57 | 220 | ± 54 | | 219 | ± 60 | * | 226 | ± 60 | | 219 | ± 52 | * | 219 | ± 60 | | 221 | ± 43 | |
| Ala | 308 | ± 70 | 330 | ± 81 | | 317 | ± 68 | * | 333 | ± 77 | * | 309 | ± 68 | | 365 | ± 68 | * | 321 | ± 68 | * |
| Val | 194 | ± 35 | 207 | ± 36 | * | 201 | ± 35 | * | 201 | ± 38 | * | 193 | ± 33 | | 213 | ± 35 | * | 208 | ± 35 | * |
| Leu | 109 | ± 21 | 117 | ± 23 | * | 112 | ± 21 | * | 111 | ± 22 | * | 109 | ± 20 | | 120 | ± 21 | * | 120 | ± 20 | * |
| Ile | 55 | ± 13 | 59 | ± 14 | | 57 | ± 14 | * | 58 | ± 16 | * | 55 | ± 12 | | 64 | ± 14 | * | 61 | ± 13 | * |
| Cys | 57 | ± 13 | 55 | ± 15 | | 57 | ± 13 | | 59 | ± 13 | * | 56 | ± 12 | | 58 | ± 13 | | 56 | ± 13 | |
| Met | 26 | ± 4 | 26 | ± 4 | | 26 | ± 4 | | 27 | ± 4 | * | 25 | ± 4 | * | 28 | ± 4 | * | 28 | ± 3 | * |
| Tyr | 63 | ± 13 | 65 | ± 13 | | 65 | ± 13 | * | 66 | ± 14 | * | 63 | ± 12 | | 68 | ± 13 | * | 63 | ± 10 | |
| Phe | 59 | ± 10 | 61 | ± 9 | | 59 | ± 9 | | 62 | ± 11 | * | 58 | ± 9 | * | 61 | ± 9 | * | 60 | ± 8 | |
| Orn | 68 | ± 15 | 66 | ± 13 | | 67 | ± 14 | * | 71 | ± 15 | * | 66 | ± 14 | * | 72 | ± 14 | * | 71 | ± 13 | * |
| His | 83 | ± 10 | 85 | ± 12 | | 84 | ± 10 | * | 84 | ± 11 | * | 83 | ± 10 | | 86 | ± 10 | * | 87 | ± 11 | * |
| Lys | 129 | ± 21 | 129 | ± 22 | | 129 | ± 20 | | 134 | ± 23 | * | 126 | ± 18 | * | 132 | ± 20 | | 138 | ± 22 | * |
| Trp | 51 | ± 9 | 51 | ± 10 | | 50 | ± 9 | | 52 | ± 10 | * | 50 | ± 9 | | 56 | ± 9 | * | 54 | ± 9 | * |
| Arg | 49 | ± 11 | 50 | ± 11 | | 49 | ± 11 | | 52 | ± 12 | * | 50 | ± 11 | * | 51 | ± 11 | * | 51 | ± 10 | * |
| Total 20 AAs | 2330 | ± 252 | 2380 | ± 265 | | 2344 | ± 245 | | 2415 | ± 287 | * | 2307 | ± 240 | | 2472 | ± 245 | * | 2425 | ± 256 | * |
AAs: amino acids
CC-SLD-: Cardiometabolic criteria negative and steatotic liver disease negative
CC+SLD-: Cardiometabolic criteria positive and steatotic liver disease negative
OBE, GLC, HT, TG and HDL were each criterion in cardiometabolic criteria (Supplemental Table S1)
*<0.05 vs. CC+SLD-
Table 4
The difference of free amino acids levels between subjects with or without steatosis according to cardiometabolic criteria score
| | | CC score (CC + SLD-) | | | | CC score (MASLD) | | |
| AAs | CC-SLD- | 1 | | 2 | | 3 | | 4 and 5 | | CC-SLD+ | | 1 | | | 2 | | | 3 | | | 4 and 5 | | |
| (nmol/mL) | (N = 1,756) | (N = 3,948) | | (N = 3,134) | | (N = 1,401 ) | | (N = 417) | | (N = 68) | | (N = 242) | | | (N = 345) | | | (N = 221) | | | (N = 82) | | |
| Thr | 183 | ± 38 | 186 | ± 39 | | 188 | ± 40 | * | 187 | ± 41 | * | 191 | ± 40 | * | 186 | ± 45 | | 185 | ± 39 | | | 186 | ± 39 | | | 182 | ± 40 | | | 181 | ± 45 | | † |
| Ser | 93 | ± 14 | 93 | ± 15 | | 93 | ± 15 | | 92 | ± 16 | | 92 | ± 15 | | 93 | ± 15 | | 93 | ± 17 | | | 92 | ± 16 | | | 92 | ± 15 | | | 93 | ± 16 | | |
| Asn | 56 | ± 11 | 56 | ± 12 | | 56 | ± 11 | * | 55 | ± 11 | * | 56 | ± 11 | | 54 | ± 11 | * | 55 | ± 13 | | | 54 | ± 10 | * | † | 54 | ± 12 | * | | 54 | ± 11 | | |
| Glu | 46 | ± 12 | 50 | ± 14 | * | 56 | ± 15 | * | 64 | ± 17 | * | 71 | ± 19 | * | 50 | ± 14 | * | 55 | ± 15 | * | † | 61 | ± 16 | * | † | 68 | ± 17 | * | † | 74 | ± 17 | * | |
| Gln | 504 | ± 60 | 502 | ± 62 | | 499 | ± 63 | * | 486 | ± 65 | * | 476 | ± 59 | * | 501 | ± 66 | | 504 | ± 59 | | | 500 | ± 63 | | | 491 | ± 62 | * | | 481 | ± 59 | * | |
| Pro | 155 | ± 40 | 159 | ± 40 | * | 167 | ± 40 | * | 180 | ± 44 | * | 190 | ± 43 | * | 160 | ± 40 | | 164 | ± 41 | * | † | 173 | ± 44 | * | † | 180 | ± 42 | * | | 187 | ± 46 | * | |
| Gly | 225 | ± 57 | 221 | ± 59 | * | 210 | ± 55 | * | 201 | ± 54 | * | 192 | ± 43 | * | 220 | ± 54 | | 207 | ± 47 | * | † | 199 | ± 47 | * | † | 199 | ± 49 | * | | 183 | ± 32 | * | |
| Ala | 308 | ± 70 | 322 | ± 72 | * | 345 | ± 74 | * | 373 | ± 74 | * | 400 | ± 71 | * | 330 | ± 81 | * | 344 | ± 68 | * | † | 371 | ± 73 | * | † | 395 | ± 76 | * | † | 411 | ± 77 | * | |
| Val | 194 | ± 35 | 201 | ± 36 | * | 214 | ± 37 | * | 228 | ± 41 | * | 243 | ± 40 | * | 207 | ± 36 | * | 213 | ± 35 | * | † | 228 | ± 36 | * | † | 237 | ± 40 | * | † | 256 | ± 41 | * | † |
| Leu | 109 | ± 21 | 112 | ± 21 | * | 119 | ± 23 | * | 127 | ± 26 | * | 136 | ± 26 | * | 117 | ± 23 | * | 117 | ± 20 | * | † | 124 | ± 21 | * | † | 128 | ± 24 | * | | 141 | ± 24 | * | |
| Ile | 55 | ± 13 | 57 | ± 14 | * | 62 | ± 16 | * | 67 | ± 18 | * | 74 | ± 18 | * | 59 | ± 14 | * | 60 | ± 15 | * | † | 66 | ± 15 | * | † | 70 | ± 18 | * | † | 77 | ± 17 | * | |
| Cys | 57 | ± 13 | 57 | ± 13 | | 60 | ± 14 | * | 62 | ± 15 | * | 64 | ± 16 | * | 55 | ± 15 | | 58 | ± 14 | | | 63 | ± 16 | * | † | 64 | ± 15 | * | | 67 | ± 17 | * | |
| Met | 26 | ± 4 | 26 | ± 4 | * | 27 | ± 4 | * | 28 | ± 4 | * | 28 | ± 4 | * | 26 | ± 4 | | 27 | ± 4 | * | † | 27 | ± 4 | * | † | 28 | ± 4 | * | | 29 | ± 4 | * | |
| Tyr | 63 | ± 13 | 65 | ± 13 | * | 69 | ± 14 | * | 72 | ± 15 | * | 76 | ± 16 | * | 65 | ± 13 | | 69 | ± 13 | * | † | 73 | ± 15 | * | † | 76 | ± 14 | * | † | 80 | ± 15 | * | |
| Phe | 59 | ± 10 | 60 | ± 10 | * | 63 | ± 11 | * | 64 | ± 11 | * | 66 | ± 11 | * | 61 | ± 9 | | 62 | ± 10 | * | † | 64 | ± 10 | * | † | 66 | ± 11 | * | † | 68 | ± 10 | * | |
| Orn | 68 | ± 15 | 68 | ± 14 | | 70 | ± 15 | * | 71 | ± 15 | * | 73 | ± 14 | * | 66 | ± 13 | | 68 | ± 15 | | | 70 | ± 14 | | | 71 | ± 16 | * | | 73 | ± 14 | * | |
| His | 83 | ± 10 | 84 | ± 10 | * | 85 | ± 11 | * | 86 | ± 11 | * | 87 | ± 11 | * | 85 | ± 12 | | 84 | ± 11 | | | 86 | ± 10 | * | | 85 | ± 11 | * | | 87 | ± 12 | * | |
| Lys | 129 | ± 21 | 130 | ± 20 | | 134 | ± 21 | * | 135 | ± 21 | * | 139 | ± 21 | * | 129 | ± 22 | | 134 | ± 19 | * | † | 136 | ± 20 | * | † | 137 | ± 19 | * | | 140 | ± 22 | * | |
| Trp | 51 | ± 9 | 51 | ± 9 | | 53 | ± 9 | * | 54 | ± 10 | * | 56 | ± 10 | * | 51 | ± 10 | | 53 | ± 9 | * | † | 55 | ± 9 | * | † | 55 | ± 10 | * | | 58 | ± 10 | * | |
| Arg | 49 | ± 11 | 50 | ± 11 | * | 52 | ± 11 | * | 53 | ± 11 | * | 56 | ± 12 | * | 50 | ± 11 | | 51 | ± 13 | * | | 51 | ± 12 | * | | 52 | ± 11 | * | | 52 | ± 11 | * | † |
| Total 20 AAs | 2330 | ± 252 | 2365 | ± 261 | * | 2432 | ± 261 | * | 2499 | ± 272 | * | 2575 | ± 261 | * | 2380 | ± 265 | | 2420 | ± 253 | * | † | 2493 | ± 252 | * | † | 2549 | ± 266 | * | † | 2612 | ± 270 | * | |
AAs: amino acids
CC+SLD-: Cardiometabolic criteria positive and steatotic liver disease negative
CC-SLD-: Cardiometabolic criteria negative and steatotic liver disease negative
CC score: the number of matches with Cardiometabolic criteria
MASLD: metabolic dysfunction-associated steatotic liver disease
*<0.05 vs. CC-SLD-
†<0.05 vs. SLD- with same CC score
Table 5
The levels of free amino acids by the change of body weight for a year.
| | CC-SLD- | | CC + SLD- | | MASLD |
| AAs | > 2% loss | | NC | > 2% gain | | | > 2% loss | | NC | > 2% gain | | | > 2% loss | | NC | > 2% gain | |
| (nmol/mL) | (N = 737) | | (N = 762) | (N = 217) | | | (N = 2.691) | | (N = 3,969) | (N = 1,989) | | | (N = 284) | | (N = 400) | (N = 189) | |
| Thr | 182 | ± 38 | | 184 | ± 38 | 185 | ± 39 | | | 186 | ± 40 | | 187 | ± 40 | 187 | ± 39 | | | 185 | ± 40 | | 185 | ± 41 | 183 | ± 41 | |
| Ser | 93 | ± 14 | | 92 | ± 14 | 93 | ± 15 | | | 94 | ± 15 | * | 92 | ± 15 | 92 | ± 16 | | | 93 | ± 17 | | 93 | ± 16 | 90 | ± 15 | * |
| Asn | 56 | ± 11 | | 56 | ± 11 | 57 | ± 11 | | | 56 | ± 11 | | 56 | ± 11 | 55 | ± 12 | | | 56 | ± 12 | * | 54 | ± 11 | 53 | ± 11 | |
| Glu | 46 | ± 12 | | 46 | ± 12 | 45 | ± 12 | | | 54 | ± 16 | * | 56 | ± 16 | 57 | ± 17 | * | | 60 | ± 16 | | 62 | ± 16 | 67 | ± 19 | * |
| Gln | 504 | ± 60 | | 505 | ± 60 | 507 | ± 62 | | | 500 | ± 63 | * | 497 | ± 62 | 493 | ± 64 | * | | 505 | ± 59 | | 501 | ± 62 | 477 | ± 63 | * |
| Pro | 151 | ± 35 | | 156 | ± 40 | 161 | ± 50 | | | 163 | ± 41 | * | 166 | ± 41 | 171 | ± 43 | * | | 169 | ± 45 | | 175 | ± 42 | 178 | ± 43 | |
| Gly | 226 | ± 60 | | 224 | ± 56 | 227 | ± 56 | | | 213 | ± 55 | | 212 | ± 56 | 213 | ± 58 | | | 203 | ± 49 | | 201 | ± 47 | 192 | ± 42 | * |
| Ala | 303 | ± 67 | | 310 | ± 70 | 318 | ± 73 | | | 336 | ± 75 | * | 341 | ± 75 | 351 | ± 79 | * | | 366 | ± 77 | | 377 | ± 76 | 379 | ± 74 | |
| Val | 193 | ± 35 | | 194 | ± 33 | 195 | ± 39 | | | 208 | ± 38 | * | 212 | ± 38 | 216 | ± 42 | * | | 224 | ± 39 | * | 231 | ± 38 | 233 | ± 41 | |
| Leu | 109 | ± 21 | | 109 | ± 19 | 108 | ± 22 | | | 116 | ± 24 | * | 118 | ± 23 | 120 | ± 25 | * | | 123 | ± 22 | | 126 | ± 22 | 126 | ± 24 | |
| Ile | 55 | ± 13 | | 55 | ± 13 | 56 | ± 16 | | | 60 | ± 16 | * | 61 | ± 16 | 63 | ± 18 | * | | 65 | ± 16 | | 67 | ± 17 | 67 | ± 17 | |
| Cys | 58 | ± 14 | * | 56 | ± 12 | 56 | ± 17 | | | 59 | ± 14 | | 60 | ± 14 | 59 | ± 15 | * | | 61 | ± 15 | | 64 | ± 16 | 62 | ± 16 | |
| Met | 26 | ± 4 | | 26 | ± 4 | 26 | ± 4 | | | 27 | ± 4 | | 27 | ± 4 | 27 | ± 4 | | | 27 | ± 4 | | 28 | ± 4 | 28 | ± 4 | |
| Tyr | 63 | ± 12 | | 63 | ± 12 | 63 | ± 13 | | | 67 | ± 14 | * | 68 | ± 14 | 69 | ± 15 | | | 72 | ± 15 | | 74 | ± 14 | 74 | ± 15 | |
| Phe | 59 | ± 10 | | 59 | ± 9 | 59 | ± 11 | | | 61 | ± 10 | * | 62 | ± 10 | 62 | ± 10 | | | 64 | ± 11 | | 65 | ± 10 | 64 | ± 11 | |
| Orn | 68 | ± 15 | | 68 | ± 15 | 68 | ± 15 | | | 69 | ± 14 | | 70 | ± 14 | 69 | ± 15 | | | 70 | ± 15 | | 70 | ± 15 | 70 | ± 15 | |
| His | 82 | ± 11 | | 83 | ± 10 | 83 | ± 10 | | | 84 | ± 11 | * | 85 | ± 11 | 86 | ± 11 | | | 85 | ± 10 | | 86 | ± 11 | 84 | ± 11 | |
| Lys | 130 | ± 20 | | 129 | ± 20 | 128 | ± 22 | | | 132 | ± 21 | | 133 | ± 21 | 132 | ± 21 | | | 137 | ± 20 | | 137 | ± 19 | 133 | ± 20 | * |
| Trp | 51 | ± 9 | | 51 | ± 9 | 51 | ± 10 | | | 52 | ± 10 | | 52 | ± 9 | 53 | ± 9 | | | 55 | ± 10 | | 55 | ± 9 | 54 | ± 10 | |
| Arg | 49 | ± 10 | | 49 | ± 10 | 50 | ± 12 | | | 52 | ± 11 | | 51 | ± 11 | 51 | ± 12 | | | 52 | ± 12 | | 52 | ± 12 | 51 | ± 12 | |
| Total 20 AAs | 2324 | ± 241 | | 2331 | ± 250 | 2350 | ± 281 | | | 2403 | ± 264 | * | 2420 | ± 266 | 2440 | ± 281 | * | | 2486 | ± 265 | | 2516 | ± 264 | 2482 | ± 267 | |
AAs: amino acids
CC-SLD-: Cardiometabolic criteria negative and steatotic liver disease negative
CC+SLD-: Cardiometabolic criteria positive and steatotic liver disease negative
MASLD: metabolic dysfunction-associated steatotic liver disease
NC: not change
Data are presented as means ± SD. *<0.05vs. NC
The change of FAAs by progression in patients with MASH.
Next, we analyzed the changes in FAAs according to the pathological feature of the liver in patients with MASLD. As expected, The levels of Thr, Ser and Gly were significantly decreased in MASLD patients with steatosis grade 2 or 3 (Fig. 1B, Supplemental Table S4). In contrast, Leu significantly increased in patients with steatosis grade 2. Gly decreased according to inflammation grade as well as steatosis grade, while Tyr increased according to Ballooning grade (Supplemental Table S4). Consistent with these data, Thr was significantly decreased in early MASH compared to MASL. Ser and Gly also tended to decrease (Fig. 1C). Regarding fibrosis, the levels of Ser, Asn, Met, Tyr and Phe were significantly increased in F4 cirrhosis. BCAAs, especially Val, tended to increase (p = 0.09) at F2 and then decreased after F2. Accompanying these changes, Fischer’s ratio gradually decreased according to fibrosis stage (Fig. 1D, Supplemental Table S5).
The change of FAAs in liver of MASLD model mice
To explore the imbalance of FAAs and the energy metabolism in the steatotic liver, we conducted metabolomics on the liver of MASLD model mice. We confirmed that a 25-week FFC diet (Supplemental Figure S4A) induced MASLD phenotypes, including obesity, liver dysfunction, hyperglycemia, and hyperlipidemia in middle-aged mice (50-week-old) as shown in Fig. 2A. Consistent with these data, liver and adipose tissue weights increased, but muscle weight was unchanged compared to the normal diet ༈Supplemental Figure S4B, S4C༉. Pathologically, steatosis and fibrosis were observed in the liver (Fig. 2B). Electron microscopy revealed that the FFC diet led to mitochondrial dysfunction and endoplasmic reticulum (ER) stress in steatotic hepatocytes, indicated by mitochondrial round formation and ER dilation (Fig. 2B). Most of the FAAs, except for Cys and Arg, were decreased in the liver due to the FFC diet, regardless of mouse age (Supplemental Table S6). Specifically, Gly, Ser, Asn, and Tyr significantly decreased after just 2 weeks on the diet. CE-TOFMS detected 98 metabolites, including FAAs, in the liver and revealed distinct metabolic profiles between the NC and the FFC diet through principal component analysis (Supplemental Figure S4D). Pathway enrichment analysis between the NC and the FFC diet showed that Ser, Gly and Thr metabolism was highly impacted among metabolic pathways (Fig. 2C). Consistent with these data, mitochondrial dysfunction was observed in the liver fed an FFC diet, as evidenced by significant decreases in ATP, ADP, and NAD+, as well as lactate and pyruvate, which are conversion products of Ser, Gly, and Thr (Fig. 2D). RNA-seq indicated that the metabolism of these FAAs was suppressed, and glycolysis was enhanced (Fig. 2E), while the expression of representative transporters for Ser and Thr was increased in the liver of mice fed an FFC diet. Summarized Gly-Ser-Thr metabolism was shown in Fig. 2F. Overall, these results indicate that the abnormal metabolism of Gly, Ser and Thr is strongly associated with the pathogenesis of MASLD in a mouse model.
Dietary Intervention by Gly, Ser and Tyr ameliorated the pathogenesis of MASLD model mice
To explore the efficacy of dietary intervention by Gly, Ser and Thr, we compared the phenotypes of mice fed the control diet (AIN-93G) and the H-GST diet which has high Gly, Ser and Thr (Supplemental Table S2). In this experiment, the leptin deficient mouse, the ob/ob mouse, was employed (Supplemental Figure S5A) because a previous study elucidated that BCAAs were increased and Gly, Ser and Thr were decreased in plasma(She et al. 2007), which was similar to the FAAs profile in human. Interestingly, liver weight and size were significantly decreased in H-GST diet compared to the control diet although body weight was not changed (Fig. 3A, 3B). As expected, the H-GST diet improved the MASLD phenotype compared to the control diet both biochemically (Fig. 3C) and pathologically (Fig. 3D). The weights of adipose tissues and skeletal muscles were also not different between these diets (Supplemental Figure S5B). Fasting blood glucose (FBG), TG, and T-cho levels were also not different between diets (Supplemental Figure S5C). In the liver of ob/ob mice, the levels of FAAs were significantly decreased compared to wild-type mice (Fig. 3E), similar to the FFC diet (Supplemental Table S6). While the H-GST diet significantly increased the levels of Gly and Ser in the liver compared to the control diet, Thr showed the same trend. Interestingly, AAs which were low content in the H-GST diet were not decreased in the liver of mice fed H-GST diet. These results suggest that dietary interventions targeting Gly, Ser, and Thr could ameliorate the pathology of MASLD by restoring the levels of these AAs in the liver.