3.2. Qualitative and quantitative assays for glycanolytic enzymes: cellulase, pectinase, and xylanase.
During fermentation, the strains produced different glycanolytic enzymes, i.e., cellulase (CMCase), pectinase, and xylanase (Fig. S1a). The qualitative enzymatic assays show that the diameter of substrate hydrolysis increased with increasing incubation time. The strains PDF4 and XDF7(iii) produced a high amount of CMCase, while the lowest was for pectinase and xylanase (Fig. S1b). Meanwhile, the XDF1(i) strain showed moderate enzymatic activity.
The quantitative assays for glycanolytic enzymes show a significant difference in their enzyme activities compared to the qualitative tests.
CMCase:
The time course optimisation study revealed that XDF7(iii) reached the peak CMCase activity (0.032286833 µM/mL/min) on the 7th day of incubation in YP-CMC medium. PDF4 attained maximal CMCae activity (0.034298978 µM/mL/min) on the 7th day of incubation in medium YP pectin medium, with comparable activity levels (0.028771361 µM/mL/min in YP-CMC on the 7th day of incubation. XDF1(i) recorded its maximum CMCase activity (0.031454221 µM/mL/min) on day 7 in medium YP pectin (Fig. 2a).
Pectinase:
XDF7(iii) demonstrated the maximal pectinase activity (0.049642011 µM/mL/min on the 7th day of their growth in YP-pectin medium. Similarly, PDF4 achieved the highest levels of pectinase activity (0.033781464 µM/mL/min) on 7th day of incubation in YP-pectin medium. XDF1(i) attained peak pectinase activity (0.03680763 µM/mL/min) on the 7th day of its growth in YP-CMC medium, with comparable pectinase activity levels in YP-xylan (0.02921002 µM/mL/min) and YP-pectin (0.027664744 µM/mL/min) media on 7th day of incubation(Fig. 2b).
Xylanase:
The time course activity of xylanase revealed that almost all strains attained peak xylanase activity when in YP-xylan medium (Fig. 2c). PDF4 exhibited peak xylanase activity (0.016180421 µM/mL/min on the 3rd day of incubation. XDF7(iii) showed peak activity of 0.018234197 µM/mL/min on 10th day of growth in YP-xylan medium with comparable levels of activity(0.015902884 µM/mL/min) on 7th day of growth in the same medium. Similarly, XDF1(i) achieved maximal xylanase activity (0.015486578 µM/mL/min) on the 10th day of incubation in YP-xylan medium. One-way ANOVA test for the data sets is the sum of squares between groups:0.000152044, with df 2.0, within groups: 0.00759106, with df 78, Mean square between groups 7.60219E-05, and within the group with 9.73213E-05, F 0.7811. p = 0.4614. Welch F test in the case of unequal variances: F = 0.6892, df = 51.46, p = 0.5066
3.3. pH optimum for the enzymatic activity of the strains
Effect of pH on CMCase activity in different fungal strains:
The pH optimization experiment revealed that the tested strains exhibited minimal CMCase activity under highly acidic conditions, specifically at pH 3.0 to 4.0. Enzyme activity progressively decreased with increasing pH (Fig. 3a). At higher pH levels (6–10), CMCase activity was either absent or undetectable, suggesting that the enzyme is susceptible to alkaline conditions. Among the strains cultured in YP-CMC broth, strain XDF7(iii) demonstrated the highest CMCase activity (0.01302 µM/mL/min) at pH 3.0, followed by XDF1(i) (0.0121µM/mL/min at pH 3.0) and PDF4 (0.00696 µM/mL/min) at pH 4.0. Furthermore, when the strains were grown in YP-xylan and YP-pectin media, a marginal reduction in CMCase activity was observed, indicating substrate-specific regulation of enzyme expression and activity under varying environmental conditions.
Effect of pH on Pectinase activity in different fungal strains:
The pH range experiment revealed that YP-pectin is the most effective medium for inducing pectinase activity in the tested fungal strains. The results indicate that pectinase activity is optimal at acidic pH levels, particularly between pH 3.0 and 4.0, with a marked decline in enzyme activity observed as the pH increases (Fig. 3b). Among the tested strains, strain XDF7(iii) was the highest pectinase producer, showing an activity of 0.303547 µM/mL/min at pH 3.0. followed by PDF4 with 0.245313 µM/mL/min, and XDF1(i) with 0.205393 µM/mL/min, at pH 4.0.
Effect of pH on Xylanase activity in different fungal strains:
The pH range experiment demonstrated that the fungal strains exhibit maximum xylanase activity predominantly at acidic pH levels, particularly between 5.0 and 6.0. Among the tested media, YP-xylan was identified as the most suitable substrate for xylanase production, whereas YP-CMC and YP-pectin induced only negligible xylanase activity. Among the fungal strains, XDF7(iii) showed the highest xylanase activity, reaching 0.768501µM/mL/min at pH 5.0, followed by 0.563401 µM/mL/min at pH 6.0. XDF1(i) exhibited the second-highest xylanase activity (0.553409µM/mL/min) at pH 5.0. While PDF4 recorded 0.343314 µM/mL/min xylanase activity at pH 5.0 (Fig. 3c), it was also observed that the xylanase activity of the strains declined with increasing pH.
Temperature optimum for the enzymatic activity of the strains:
CMCase:
Among the temperatures tested, 37°C was found to be the optimal temperature for CMCase activity (Fig. 4a). Additionally, YP-CMC medium was determined to be the most favourable medium for supporting this CMCase activity. At pH 3.0, XDF7(iii) demonstrated the highest CMCase (0.013017µM/mL/min) followed by XDF1(i) (0.012 µM/mL/min and PDF4(0.0048 µM/mL/min). At 27°C and 47°C, CMCase activity of the fungal strains was either below detectable limits or completely absent.
Pectinase:
Among the tested temperatures, viz. at 27°C, 37°C, and 47°C, both 27°C and 37°C supported moderate levels of pectinase activity, with YP-pectin as the most suitable medium at pH 5.6 (Fig. 4b). The strain PDF4 exhibited pectinase activity of 0.14258 µM/mL/min and 0.14222 µM/mL/min at 27°C and 37°C, respectively. XDF7(iii) showed 0.138431 µM/mL/min and 0.179781 µM/mL/min pectinase activity at 27°C and 37°C, respectively. XDF1(i) showed 0.138002 µM/mL/min and 0.145084 µM/mL/min pectinase activity at 27°C and 37°C, respectively. Pectinase activity was markedly reduced at 47°C, suggesting that elevated temperatures adversely affect the enzyme's catalytic efficiency.
Xylanase:
Among the three tested temperatures, viz. 27°C, 37°C, and 47°C, the temperature of 37°C was found to be the most favorable, and YP-xylan was identified as the most suitable medium for xylanase enzyme activity (Fig. 4c and d). At 37°C temperature and pH 5.0, XDF7(iii) exhibited the highest xylanase activity of 0.768501µM/mL/min, followed by XDF1(i) (0.5534093µM/mL/min) and PDF4 (0.343314µM/mL/min). In contrast, at 27°C, xylanase activity was significantly reduced across all strains. The enzyme activity at this temperature ranged approximately from 0.089 to 0.104 µM/mL/min. At 27°C and pH 5.0, PDF4 exhibited the highest enzyme activity (0.1049996µM/mL/min) followed by XDF7(iii) (0.0929735µM/mL/min) and XDF1(i) (0.0895508µM/mL/min). At 47°C, xylanase activity in all tested strains was either below the detectable limit or completely absent, indicating a potential loss of enzyme stability or function at higher temperatures.
Enzymatic activity of the strains on natural substrates:
CMCase:
In the case of CMCase, all strains exhibited very low enzyme activity on Lemon (Musambi) peel, while no detectable activity was observed on Sugarcane bagasse across all incubation periods(Fig. 5a). Among the tested strains, XDF7(iii) emerged as the highest CMCase producer, showing peak activity(0.011714µM/mL/min) on the 3rd day of incubation on Musambi peel. This was followed by PDF4 (0.011388 µM/mL/min) on the 7th day. XDF1(i) showed the highest amount of CMCase activity on the 7th day of incubation, measuring 0.011598 µM/mL/min.
Pectinase:
All fungal strains utilised both musambi peel and sugarcane bagasse for pectinase production, with a general preference for musambi peel. Among the tested strains, the XDF7(iii) ranked the highest in pectinase production, with the highest activity recorded on the 3rd day (0.857629 µM/mL/min) of incubation utilising musambi peel, followed by the 7th (0.8159919µM/mL/min) and 10th day (0.7125442 µM/mL/min) of growth on the same substrate (Fig. 5b). With sugarcane bagasse, moderate levels of pectinase were also produced; however, enzyme activity declined over time, with the highest activity noted on the 3rd day (0.5945022µM/mL/min) of incubation.XDF1(i) demonstrated considerable pectinase activity, achieving peak enzyme levels (0.8106979µM/mL/min) on the 7th day of incubation with musambi peel. When grown on sugarcane bagasse, the highest pectinase activity (0.5000687 µM/mL/min) was observed on the 10th day.PDF4 also proved to be a notable pectinase producer on musambi peel, with peak activity (0.7362957 µM/mL/min) on the 3rd day of incubation. When grown on sugarcane bagasse, pectinase activity peaked on the 10th day (0.5608782 µM/mL/min).
Xylanase:
All five fungal strains demonstrated varying levels of xylanase production when grown on natural lignocellulosic substrates, with differences observed in both substrate preference and incubation time.XDF7(iii) utilized both musambi peel and sugarcane bagasse effectively. It recorded the highest xylanase activity (1.0912764µM/mL/min) among all strains on the 3rd day of incubation on lemon (Musambi) peel and the second-highest activity (0.9921957µM/mL/min) on the 7th day on sugarcane bagasse (Fig. 5c). Additionally, it maintained good enzyme activity on the 3rd (0.9194809 µM/mL/min)and 10th day (0.9405737 µM/mL/min) on sugarcane bagasse, as well as on the 7th day (0.8481538 µM/mL/min) on musambi peel. However, a decline was noted by the 10th day, with a measurement of 0.6394458 µM/mL/min. PDF4 also demonstrated good substrate utilization efficiency, showing a preference for lemon (Musambi) peel. It recorded its highest xylanase activity (0.7687782 µM/mL/min) on the 7th day of growth on the lemon (Musambi) peel substrate followed by 0.7079975 µM/mL/min xylanase activity on 3rd day of growth on sugarcane bagasse, XDF1(i) exhibited only moderate activity on lemon (Musambi) peel, with the 3rd day (0.5166818µM/mL/min) yielding the highest output, followed by the 7th day (0. 5081707µM/mL/min). A sharp decline in xylanase activity (0.2088005 µM/mL/min) was observed on 10th day of growth. Sugarcane bagasse was not a suitable substrate for XDF1(i), as xylanase activity remained consistently low throughout all incubation days. The combined box plot (Fig. 5d), the matrix plot (Fig. 5e), and the PCA (Fig. 5f) analyses of the data sets also project the same observation, focusing on the strains XDF7(iii), which emerged as a strong xylanase producer in the natural substrates musambi peel and sugarcane bagasse. This production level was also higher than that of single-carbohydrate sources, such as pectins and birchwood xylan. The one-way ANOVA test for the data sets yields a sum of squares between groups of 0.084567, with a degree of freedom (df) of 4.0, and a sum of squares within groups of 1.09144, with a df of 70. The mean square between groups is 0.0211417, and the mean square within groups is 0.015592. The F-value is 1.356. p = 0.2581.