3.1 Effect of the Functionalization on Bonding
Most PCBs that are available on the market consist of phenolic resin-based polymers with fillers. These phenolic resins typically possess active hydroxyl groups, allowing for potential esterification reactions. The significance lies in the fact that surface modification through esterification reactions enables the attachment of the monomer groups, here acrylates and methacrylates, to the surface. These groups have the capability to copolymerize with the monomers in the resin which results in a strong adhesion of the printed structure to the PCB. To verify this, we conducted an experiment by immersing the PCBs in a mixture of methacrylic anhydride and DMAP. Subsequently, we analyzed the changes in the infrared absorption of the PCBs before and after the process using FTIR. The FTIR results, depicted in Fig. 3a, revealed a prominent absorption peak near 1716 cm-1 after the immersion in methacrylic anhydride. In the infrared spectrum, this absorption peak is indicative of the presence of a strong ester C = O bond, which is characteristic of the methacrylate ester structure. To confirm the FTIR results, a tensile test was conducted with a dog-bone shape specimen attached to the chip. The holder to the chip has a dimension of 4 x 4 mm² and the tensile test speed was 1 mm/min. As shown in Fig. 3b, the PCB without functionalization delaminated at a force of 13 N, whereas the PCB with functionalization delaminated at a force of 32 N. Therefore, these findings confirm the successful modification of the PCB surface.
3.2 Liquid Metal Valving Mechanism
The valving mechanism of the present microvalve, directly 3D printed on a PCB, is based on the electrochemical actuation of LM, i.e. Galinstan plugs. As discussed, Galinstan is a liquid metal alloy and is composed of gallium, indium, and tin (68.5 wt% Ga, 21 wt% In, 10 wt% Sn; melting point: 13.2°C) (Daeneke et al. 2018). Despite its attracting properties as a liquid metal at room temperature, including high electrical conductivity (around 3.4 × 106 S m− 1, about 17 times lower than copper), low viscosity (about twice the viscosity of water), high surface tension (around 600–700 mN m− 1), extremely low toxicity, and negligible vapor pressures (< 10− 6 Pa) (Khoshmanesh et al. 2017), the oxide skin hinders its flow in microchannels. A nanometer-thick oxide skin is formed on its surface when exposed to air which affects its conductivity and also surface adhesion. Manipulating Galinstan in a microfluidic channel requires an electrolyte that can, firstly, remove this oxide skin and, secondly, provides enough ion conductivity to actuate the Galinstan plug. Based on previous experience (Bhagwat et al. 2022), NaOH meets both criteria. Following filling the channels and chambers with NaOH and injecting the Galinstan to fill three chambers, electric potential is applied to the electrodes. The Galinstan plug starts moving under the applied electric field (Fig. 4a-b). Upon clearing the chamber intersecting with the flow channel (the vertical channel from inlet to outlet), the valve goes from CLOSED state to OPEN state. We defined the CLOSED-state of the valve when Galinstan plug blocks the vertical channel. Under certain voltage, the plug moves by one chamber, clears the vertical channel and the microvalve switches to the OPEN-state. We observed that two parameters play roles mainly in maintaining the microvalve in bistable modes: the applied electric potential and the geometry of the valve containing LM plugs.
3.2.1 Modulated Voltage for LM Actuation
One common challenge in the electrochemical actuation of LMs in microchannels filled with electrolytes is the hydrolysis and subsequent gas formation the channels. The bubbles not only result in blocking the microchannels, but also create an insulating layer between the electrodes and the LM plug, hindering its actuation and displacement. The required voltage to move the LM plug depends on several factors including the plug size, electrolyte concentration, channel dimensions, and voltage type and range. Aiming for low power applications, our experiments did not show significant changes in the results changing the electrolyte concentration. Therefore, we focused mainly on looking into the effect of applied voltages and the architecture of the valve. For lower voltage range and more precise control over the plug motion in the chambers, we selected square-wave over DC voltage. This is mainly due to the fact that an aqueous NaOH solution imposes hydrolysis limitations under applied voltages approximately at 1.2 V. When applying a DC voltage with constant current, the voltage required to move Galinstan is more than 4 V which leads to instantly the formation of air bubbles. Moreover, Gough et al. had presented the effect of implementing low AC voltages to successfully break the continuously regenerating oxide skin, in comparison to high DC voltages which eventually result in slow LM plug movement due to the oxide skin (Gough et al. 2014). Therefore, we selected the square-wave signal over DC voltages. The actuation of Galinstan plugs benefits from such modulated voltage, which does not apply a constant current to the system and provides switching polarity at constant frequency intervals. A waveform generator (Fig. S 2) generates the modulated signals and is connected to the electrodes through two wires soldered on the gold pads. In this work, we investigated the voltage amplitude and frequency. Initially, we observed that changing the voltage from 0.5 Vpp to 1.5 Vpp was not strong enough to move the plug. However, at 2 Vpp, the Galinstan plug started moving. Moreover, we found the frequency should not be too high or too low, hence there is a frequency interval to move the plug. We characterized the valve for a range of frequencies changing them from 1 Hz to 35 Hz at this specified voltage (2 Vpp). For frequencies lower than 5 Hz or higher than 25 Hz, the plug vibrates only in place (actuation video S 1) and thus does not provide valving capability. We achieved a reproducible and stable actuation between 5–25 Hz. Figure 4c presents the characterization of the microvalve response time implemented at three frequencies (5, 15 and 25 Hz), the valve response time was statistically analyzed with 6 test per each frequency value between the OPEN and CLOSED states. At 25 Hz the average response time is approximately 2700 ms with high error margin (actuation video S 2), as the plug moves too fast preferring to remain in the initial state. As going down to 15 Hz (actuation video S 3), the average response time improved to approximately 650 ms. The best response time with reproducible actuation in our observation was 250 ms which happened at 5 Hz (actuation video S 4), as shown in Fig. 4d.
3.2.2 3D Geometry for the LM Microvalve
Given the nature of Galinstan, its surface tension and actuation, another factor plays a key role on a LM microvalve, i.e., the valve’s geometric architecture. Due to the high surface tension of Galinstan, and its coalescence tendency, Galinstan plugs would prefer to remain connected while moving in uneven channels. As shown in Fig. 4c, a caterpillar design allows the LM to fill the entire chamber in the vicinity of the inlet and the outlet channels. The air vents on the right and left sides of the valve (Fig. 2c-d) are intended for three purposes: a) to give the liquid enough space to move while actuating the LM without inducing pressure in the system; b) to provide a larger contact area with the electrodes for enough electric field; and c) to move away any air bubble generated on the electrodes. To control the direction of the liquid towards the outlet channel, the dimensions of the nozzles to the air vents were set to half of the inlet/outlet channels.
3.2.3 Valve-Pressure Test
The valve was tested using the hydrostatic pressure method. A beaker with a tube was placed at the same level as the chip located. NaOH solution with a food color was poured into the beaker and the pressure applied to the chip was calculated. We observed that the valve did hold pressure until 2 mbar, then started leaking from the side channel. The pressure the valve can hold would be further increased by reducing the channel size by using a higher resolution printer.