In the present study, we aimed to decipher the protective effect of combined T3 and BAI treatment on adenine-induced CKD in old mice. As per our previous findings [17, 61], we intend to bidirectionally target CKD using the thyroid hormones T3 and BAI. T3 was used with the intention of maintaining a normal HPT axis in CKD, whereas BAI was used to counteract the exaggerated upregulation of the Wnt/β-catenin pathway, as previously reported. Interestingly, we found that both treatments could enhance Klotho via different targets. Furthermore, as CKD predisposes individuals to other complications, such as anemia, dyslipidemia, cardiovascular disease, and mineral bone disorders, we intend to evaluate the therapeutic potential of individual (either T3 or BAI) versus combined (T3 + BAI) treatment for these complications.
Serum and urine biomarkers, including creatinine, urea, BUN, and albumin, are used as standard clinical indices to assess kidney disorders leading to CKD [51, 62–64]. The adenine oral dose significantly impaired kidney function, as evidenced by increased serum creatinine, urea, BUN, and urine albumin levels, followed by decreased urinary excretion of creatine and urea. In this study, when CKD mice were treated with T3, BAI, or their combination (T3 + BAI), all the abnormal serum parameters reverted toward their normal range, indicating that there were improvements in kidney function after the treatments.
Research indicates that CKD significantly impacts the HPT axis, impairing thyroid hormone metabolism [5, 65, 66]. Subclinical hypothyroidism prevalence rises with decreasing GFR and advancing age, often accompanied by lower serum T3 and T4 levels and higher TSH levels [7]. Our findings align with these reports, showing reduced T3 and elevated TSH in CKD mice (Supplementary Results S1).
To address HPT axis dysregulation, exogenous T3 was administered at a previously reported dose [35, 36]. After 12 hours of treatment, TSH levels significantly decreased in the T3 and T3 + BAI groups, while no notable changes occurred in BAI-only animals due to T3's biological half-life. Further studies are needed to refine the dosage and timing of thyroid hormone therapy, given the study's limitations in pharmacokinetic analyses in CKD models.
Glomerulosclerosis, interstitial fibrosis, and tubular atrophy are symptoms of renal fibrosis resulting from the inability of kidney tissue to be repaired after long-term, chronic damage [67]. Renal cells are replaced by ECM in the glomeruli and interstitium as CKD progresses, which is accompanied by the loss of renal cells [68, 69]. Morphological analysis of CKD kidneys using H&E and Masson’s trichrome staining revealed increased inflammatory infiltration, protein casts, and ECM deposition following adenine treatment. However, T3 and BAI combination therapy significantly reduced fibrosis and ECM deposition, demonstrating a protective effect against further deterioration in aged CKD mice.
Klotho is primarily expressed on the cell surface of DCT and PCT in the kidney and is maintained at normal levels under physiological conditions [70–74]. However, CKD leads to reduced Klotho levels, evident in both nephritic dysfunction and animal models. CKD decreases mRNA expression of M-Kl and Sp-Kl and reduces α-Kl and S-Kl protein levels [75, 76].
T3 and BAI treatments restored Klotho mRNA and protein expression toward normal, with the combination treatment showing the greatest effect. BAI likely increases Klotho by inhibiting the Wnt/β-catenin pathway, while T3 directly activates Klotho, as suggested by previous findings.
The standard progression route for CKDs, including renal tubulointerstitial fibrosis, often leads to ESRD. Recent findings highlight GSK3β's role in renal tubular cell profibrogenic plasticity during CKD progression, particularly through its interaction with pathways like TGF-β1 signaling [46]. Elevated GSK-3β expression in glomeruli and renal tubular cells is linked to kidney diseases like proteinuric glomerulopathies and podocyte damage [77–79]. Determining changes in GSK3β expression after treatment is essential. CKD kidneys show elevated GSK-3β levels, indicating tubular inflammation and damage. While individual treatments with T3 and BAI downregulated GSK-3β, they did not significantly reduce fibrosis. In contrast, combined therapy markedly reduced GSK-3β expression, likely by stabilizing Klotho expression. T3 enhances Klotho levels, while BAI reduces its transcriptional inhibition by β-catenin, as Klotho downregulates GSK-3β expression [80].
The canonical Wnt/β-catenin pathway, an evolutionarily conserved signaling pathway, controls the pathogenesis of many diseases. Overexpression of this pathway has been observed in different types of kidney injury [81–84]. Sustained activation of the canonical Wnt/β-catenin pathway drives acute kidney injury (AKI) to CKD progression [85]. Adenine-fed animals displayed enhanced activation of the Wnt/β-catenin pathway, as evidenced by increased mRNA expression of various Wnt ligands, reduced CK-1 protein levels, and elevated β-catenin protein production in the kidney. The natural compound BAI effectively suppressed the elevated mRNA expression of all Wnt ligands in CKD mice. Moreover, T3 and BAI effectively restored β-catenin and CK-1 expression levels in CKD mice, with the combination therapy further promoting β-catenin degradation. We propose that T3’s inhibitory effect on the Wnt pathway may be mediated through its ability to upregulate Klotho expression, as Klotho can inhibit the Wnt/β-catenin pathway without directly affecting Wnt ligand mRNA expression. (Add t3 Klotho paper) [86–88]. Similarly, since the highest levels of Klotho expression were observed with the combined T3 and BAI treatment, we speculate that BAI’s inhibition of the Wnt/β-catenin pathway may prevent this major upregulated pathway, observed in CKD, from suppressing Klotho expression. This mechanism likely ensures the sustained upregulation of Klotho protein in the kidney, contributing to its pronounced beneficial effects.
TGF-β is a key profibrotic regulator in CKD, promoting ECM accumulation, preventing its breakdown, and activating myofibroblasts [89–92]. Therapeutic strategies targeting TGF-β in experimental and clinical CKD models have shown reduced renal fibrosis and injury [93, 94]. Studies in renal epithelial cells reveal that Klotho inhibition increases TGF-β1 expression, while TGF-β1 suppresses Klotho, indicating that reduced Klotho promotes TGF-β1 activity, creating a cycle contributing to renal fibrosis in CKD [95]. In this study, adenine-induced CKD mice showed increased TGF-β mRNA expression, linked to activation of the Wnt/β-catenin pathway and reduced Klotho expression. However, the combination treatment group exhibited a significant reduction in TGF-β levels. These findings align with previous reports [96], suggesting that Klotho inhibits TGF-β signaling, offering potential benefits in suppressing renal fibrosis.
Fibrosis in CKD is closely associated with increased inflammation, characterized by elevated levels of inflammatory cytokines such as NF-κB, TNF-α, and interleukins in adenine-induced CKD mice. Klotho, as an anti-inflammatory regulator, can mitigate NF-κB activity by reducing proinflammatory gene transcription [97]. Consistently, our study observed a marked increase in NF-κB and IL-6 protein expression in the kidneys of CKD mice. We hypothesize that our dual treatment strategy may counteract inflammation by enhancing Klotho expression. Notably, the anti-inflammatory effects of T3 and BAI were most pronounced in the combination therapy (T3 + BAI) group, potentially attributable to the significant upregulation of Klotho expression induced by the combined treatment.
CKD is marked by oxidative stress due to reduced antioxidant activity and excessive ROS production [98], with a strong link between ROS generation and Klotho levels. Klotho mitigates oxidative stress by downregulating insulin/IGF-1/PI3K signaling, activating FoxO, and inducing MnSOD formation [99]. Additionally, free radicals (e.g., H2O2, O2•–) are generated during hypoxanthine/xanthine conversion to uric acid via xanthine oxidase (XO) [100–102]. Adenine-induced overproduction of hypoxanthine elevates XO expression, causing oxidative damage in CKD kidneys [103]. To evaluate the kidney's antioxidant defense, we measured catalase and SOD activity. As anticipated, adenine-induced CKD kidneys showed reduced expression of these antioxidant enzymes. All treatment groups effectively restored their altered activity levels. (Supplementary Results S2).
CKD is associated with various complications, including anemia, mineral and bone disorders, dyslipidemia, and cardiovascular conditions. We investigated whether our dual treatment offers protection solely against CKD or also mitigates these associated complications. Notably, the combined treatment demonstrated protective effects against all the aforementioned CKD-related complications.
In the case of CKD-induced anemia, which arises from mechanisms such as reduced erythropoietin synthesis, hypothyroidism, and shortened red blood cell lifespan [5, 104], the protective effect was mediated by T3 but not by BAI. This can be attributed to T3's well-established role in stimulating erythropoiesis [105–107].
To examine its effect on mineral and bone disorders, we measured phosphate (Pi) and calcium (Ca²⁺) levels, commonly altered in CKD (increased Pi and decreased Ca²⁺ levels) [15]. Since Klotho regulates phosphate and calcium homeostasis, our combined treatment normalized these levels via the actions of both T3 and BAI. This was further supported by increased mRNA expression of kidney phosphate and calcium channels regulated by Klotho. Mineral and bone disorders in CKD are also driven by elevated alkaline phosphatase (ALP) activity and reduced vitamin D3 levelsv [108].. These abnormalities were corrected by T3, highlighting its additional protective role. Thus, T3 and BAI function through distinct mechanisms to address CKD-induced anemia and mineral and bone disorders.
CKD is a systemic condition often accompanied by dyslipidemia. As renal function declines, hyperlipidemia becomes more common, with elevated LDL cholesterol and triglyceride levels correlating with the severity of impairmen [5]. Furthermore, dyslipidemia and elevated serum TSH levels are independent risk factors for cardiovascular diseases [109, 110].
The bidirectional treatment effectively reversed the altered lipid profile and protected against dyslipidemia (Supplementary Results S3). To evaluate its protective effect on CVD, we initially assessed coronary disease risk using lipid profile markers by calculating the Atherogenic Index (AI) and Cardiac Risk Index (CRI). CKD mice showed a higher CVD risk, which decreased with T3 and BAI treatments, with the combined treatment providing the greatest reduction.
Given the elevated CVD risk in CKD mice, we examined heart tissue for fibrosis using H&E staining. Notably, CKD hearts displayed significant fibrosis. Similar to findings in the kidney, combined treatment offered superior protection in the heart compared to individual therapies, as evidenced by reduced fibrotic areas, highlighting its protective role against CVD.
Increased oxidative stress in the kidney prompted an evaluation of antioxidant enzyme activity in heart tissue. Both catalase and SOD activities were diminished in CKD mice but improved with treatment, demonstrating the protective effects of Klotho in cardiac tissue as well.